Mr. Thevakumars ordeal did not end there. When he landed in Turkey. he was jailed for four days by immigration officials. who beat and interrogated him before handing him over to regular police. When he was finally released by the police. he was referred to a United Nations office in Ankara. halfway across the country from Istanbul. After 15 days of travel wearing clothes that were completely unsuitable for the Turkish winter. he finally arrived at the U.N. office and requested refugee status and asked not to be sent back to Sri Lanka. He is currently living in a Red Cross facility in Turkey. These storiesjust two of the many stories demonstrating the human cost of expedited removalgo a long way toward showing the inhumanity of the new immigration regime that Congress imposed in 1996. But refugees are not the only people affected by expedited removal. Human rights groups have also documented numerous cases where people traveling to the United States on business. with proper travel documents. have been removed based on the socalled "sixth sense** of a lowlevel INS officer who suspected that their facially valid documents were fraudulent. In other words. the damage done by expedited removal also threatens the increasingly international American economyif businesspeople from around the world are treated disrespectfully at our ports of entry. they are likely to take their business elsewhere. But perhaps the most distressing part of expedited removal is that there is no way for us to know how many deserving refugees have been excluded. Because secondary inspection interviews are conducted in secret. we typically only learn about mistakes when refugees manage to make it back to the U.S. a second time. like Dem. or when they are deported to a third country they passed through on their way to the U.S.. like Mr. Thevakumar. This uncertainty should lead us to be especially wary of continuing this failed experiment. As I said. my bill would limit the use of expedited removal to times of immigration emergencies. defined as the arrival or imminent arrival of aliens that would substantially exceed the INS ability to control our borders. The bill gives the Attorney General the discretion to declare an emergency migration situation. and the declaration is good for 90 days. During those 90 days. the INS would be authorized to use expedited removal. The Attorney General is given the power to extend the declaration for further periods of 90 days. in consultation with the House and Senate Judiciary Committees. s This framework allows the government to take extraordinary steps when a true immigration emergency threatens our ability to patrol our borders. At the same time. it recognizes that expedited removal is an extraordinary step. and is not an appropriate measure under ordinary circumstances. This bill also provides safeguards that will ensure that refugees are assured of some due process rights. even during immigration emergencies. First. aliens would be given the right to have an immigration judge review a removal order. and would have the right both to speak before the immigration judge on their own behalf and to be represented at the hearing at their own expense. To make these rights meaningful. immigration officers would be required to inform aliens of their rights before they are removed or withdraw their application to enter the country. This provision takes away from lowlevel INS officers the unilateral power to remove an alien from the United States. Second. expedited removal will not apply to aliens who have fled from a country that engages in serious human rights violations. The Attorney General. in consultation with the Assistant Secretary of State for Democracy. Human Rights. and Labor. will develop and maintain a list of such countries. This will help ensure that even during an immigration emergency. we will provide added protection for many of our most vulnerable refugees. Third. this bill reforms the procedures used to determine whether an applicant who seeks asylum has a credible fear of persecution. If an asylum officer determines that an applicant does not have a credible fear of persecution. the applicant will now have a right to a prompt review by an immigration judge. The applicant will have the right to appear at that review hearing and to be represented. at the applicants expense. In addition to providing procedural guarantees. the bill also redefines "credible fear of persecution" as a claim for asylum that is not clearly fraudulent and is related to the criteria for granting asylum. In combination. these changes will make it easier for aliens requesting asylum in the United States to receive an appropriate asylum hearing before an immigrant judge. Fourth. the bill clarifies that the Attorney General is not obligated to detain asylum applicants while their claims are pending. Asylum seekers are not criminals and they do not deserve to be imprisoned or detained against their will. There may be cases where detention is appropriate. and this bill allows for such cases. but I believe that that power should only be used in very rare cases. After all. these applicants have by definition demonstrated a credible fear of persecution. Moreover. detaining asylum applicants imposes a significant burden on the taxpayers. who of course must foot the bill for the detention. This bill also gives the Attorney General the ability to release an asylum applicant from detention pending a final determination of credible fear of persecution. Finally. this Refugee Protection Act also addresses a few other problems that have arisen under the restrictive immigration laws Congress passed in 1996. First. it gives aliens the opportunity to demonstrate good cause for filing for asylum after the oneyear time limit for claims has expired. By definition. worthy asylum applicants have arrived in the United States following traumatic experiences abroad. They often must spend their first months here learning the language and adjusting to a culture that in many cases is extraordinarily different from the one they know. Therefore. although I can understand the desire to have asylum seekers submit timely applications. we must apply the oneyear rule with some discretion and common sense. Indeed. when the Senate passed the 1996 immigration law. it contained a broad "good cause" exception that did not survive to become part of the final legislation. The Senate should take up this issue again: we were right in 1996. and the need is still there today. In a similar vein. the bill allows asylum applicants whose claims have been rejected to submit a second application where they can show good cause. No one wants to allow aliens to submit repeated applications and drain the resources of our INS officers and immigration courts. But there are exceptional cases where a second application is justified. beyond the "changed circumstances" exception that exists under current law. For example. extraordinarily worthy asylum applicants. unfamiliar with the United States and its legal system. might submit an application without the benefit of counsel and without an understanding of the legal requirements of a successful asylum claim. Such people deserve a second chance to demonstrate that they deserve to receive asylum. In conclusion. I point out that even in 1996. a year in which immigration was as unpopular in this Capitol as I can remember. this body agreed that expedited removal was inappropriate for a country of our ideals and our historic commitment to human rights. And that agreement cut across party lines. as many of my Republican colleagues voted to implement expedited removal only in times of immigration emergencies. I urge them. as well as my fellow Democrats. to support this legislation and to work for its passage before the end of the 106th Congress.
Keywords matched
immigrant Asylum seekers seeks asylum deported refugees immigration Refugee refugee asylum applicant asylum officer asylum claim asylum seekers asylum applicants