Session #106 · 1999–2001

Speech #1060091076

Justice. State. and the Judiciary Appropriations bill. proposed to slash SCAAP funding by 83 percent. to only $100 million. for reasons that escape me. In the words of the U.S./Mexico Border Counties Coalition. "-Given this programs history of not meeting its obligations to state and local governments even at higher levels of funding. this latest action will in essence leave state and local taxpayers to foot the Federal governments bill for the incarceration of criminal undocumented immigrants." A June 21. 1999. letter from the Governors of Arizona. California. New York. New Jersey. and Illinois to members of the United States Senate makes the same point: "Control of the nations borders is under the exclusive jurisdiction of the Federal government. yet State and local governments bear the brunt of the costs when the Federal government fails to meet its responsibility to prevent illegal immigration. By cutting funding for SCAAP by 83 percent. the Senate is abandoning its responsibility and forcing the states to pay for a Federally mandated service." It is my hope that Congress will restore SCAAP funding to at least $500 million. as the President requested for fiscal 2000 to help meet the needs of local communities across the country. The legislation Senator KYL and I are introducing today would actually expand the State Criminal Alien Assistance Program by authorizing funding for state and local needs that currently go unmet. Although states receive Federal reimbursement for part of the cost of incarcerating illegal adult aliens. the Federal government does not reimburse States or units of local government for expenditures for illegal juvenile aliens. Nor does it reimburse states and localities for costs associated with processing criminal illegal aliens. including court costs. county attorney costs. costs for criminal proceedings that do not involve going to trial. indigent defense costs. and unsupervised probation costs. Our legislation would authorize the Federal government to reimburse such costs to States and localities that suffer a substantially disproportionate share of the impact of criminal illegal aliens on their law enforcement and criminal justice systems. It would also authorize additional Federal reimbursement for emergency health services furnished by States and localities to undocumented aliens. Reimbursement to States and localities for criminal alien incarceration is woefully underfunded according to the existing limited criteria for SCAAP. which do not take into account the full detention and processing costs for illegal aliens. Nor does the existing SCAAP provide necessary support to local communities for the cost of emergency care for illegal immigrants. a growing problem in the Southwest. and one exacerbated by the increasingly desperate measures taken by undocumented aliens to cross our border with Mexico. Our legislation thus authorizes the expansion of SCAAP to cover costs wrongly borne by local communities under current lawcosts which are a Federal responsibility and should not be shirked by those in Washington who do not live with the problem of illegal immigration in their midst. As my colleagues know. illegal immigrants who successfully transit our Southwest border rapidly disperse throughout the United States. That SCAAP funds flow to all 50 states reflects the pressures such aliens place on public services around the country. I hope the Senate will act expeditiously on this important legislation to alleviate those pressures by compensating state and local units for the costs they incur as unwitting hosts to undocumented aliens. even as we continue to fund border enforcement measures to reduce the flow of illegal immigrants into this country.
Keywords matched
undocumented illegal immigrants immigrants border enforcement illegal immigration illegal aliens

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Criminal Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JOHN MCCAIN
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
AZ
Gender
M
Date
1999-10-07
Speech ID
1060091076
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →