Session #106 · 1999–2001

Speech #1060087370

This leaves only three days to recruit U.S. workersa scenario utterly designed for failure. In the meantime. many agricultural employers have elaborate recruitment networks that have been seeking foreign guestworkers for months. I recognize that the H2A law contains job preference requirements for U.S. workers. But there exist great economic incentives for H2A program employers to hire foreign guest workers rather than domestic farmworkers. Guestworkers are far more docile and compliant than U.S. workers who have legal protections. Also. employers save money because guestworkers wages are not subject to unemployment taxes or Social Security contributions. Once DOL has give approval to hire foreign guestworkers. U.S. farmworkers know that they usually wont be welcome at those jobs. The General Accounting Office report on the H2A program made recommendations about the very issues the McConnell rider addresses. and the McConnell amendment is inconsistent with the GAO recommendations. The GAO recommended shortening the H2A progress. which the Department of Labor recently did through regulation changes. But the GAO warned that recruitment of U.S. workers should not be reduced and that is precisely what the McConnell amendment does. I am firmly opposed to the conference committee report because this appropriations bill contains the McConnell amendment that unjustifiably denies jobs to the poorest of the working poor.
Identified stereotypes
Guestworkers are far more docile and compliant than U.S. workers who have legal protections.
Keywords matched
H2A

Classification

Also mentioned
U.S. workers domestic farmworkers
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
HOWARD BERMAN
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
CA
Gender
M
Date
1999-09-30
Speech ID
1060087370
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →