Session #106 · 1999–2001

Speech #1060061551

A bit of history is in order. The JacksonVanik amendment was the vision of Senator Henry M. Jackson of Washington. who. in 1972. first proposed: ... an unprecedented measure to bring the blessings of liberty to these brave men and women who have asked only for the chance to find freedom in a new land. "Scoop" Jacksons amendment was precipitated by the decision of the Soviet Union. in August 1972. to assess exorbitant fees on persons wishing to emigrate. Cloaked as "education reimbursement fees" or "diploma taxes." the Soviet authorities argued that emigrants owed an obligation to reimburse the Government for their free education. since. by reason of their departure. the emigrants would no longer put their education to use for the benefit of Soviet society. The exit taxes applied to all emigrants. but affected primarily Soviet Jews wishing to emigrate to Israel or the United States. Thus was born the JacksonVanik amendment. Representative Charles Vanik of Ohio was the chief sponsor in the House. The amendmentSection 402 of the Trade Act of 1974provides that no country shall be eligible to receive Normal Trade Relations tariff treatment or to participate in any United States Government programs that extend credit or credit guarantees or investment guarantees if that country: (1) denies its citizens the right or opportunity to emigrate. (2) imposes more than a nominal tax on emigration or on the visas or other documents required for emigration. for any purpose or cause whatsoever. or (3) imposes more than a nominal tax. levy. fine. fee. or other charge on any citizen as a consequence of the desire of such citizen to emigrate to the country of his choice. Under the law. the President may waive these restrictions if he determines that: * * * such waiver will substantially promote the objectives of this section ... and he has received assurances that the emigration practices of that country will henceforth lead substantially to the achievement of the objectives of this section. The United States has granted NTR status to China since 1980. on the basis of a waiver of the JacksonVanik provisions. Vietnam does not yet enjoy NTR status. but. since 1998. when the President first waived the JacksonVanik requirements. U.S. exports to Vietnam and investment projects in that country have been eligible for certain U.S. Government credits and credit and investment guarantees issued by the United States ExportImport Bank. the Overseas Private Investment Corporation and the United States Department of Agriculture. The issue before the Senate. then. is whether the Senate agrees with the Presidents assessment of the emigration policies and practices of China and Vietnam. At stake are our economic relations with those countries. The first point to be made is that the authors of the JacksonVanik amendment had neither China nor Vietnam in mind when they drafted their provision. The amendment was a creature of the Cold War. and is today an anachronism in many respects. The Presidents June 3. 1999 report to the Congress. which accompanied his determination to extend the JacksonVanik waiver to China for another year. made the following points: In FY 1998. 27.776 U.S. immigrant visas were issued to Chinese nationals abroad. up slightly from FY 1997 . . . and up to the numerical limitation under U.S. law .... The principal constraint on increased emigration continues to be the capacity and willingness of other nations to absorb Chinese immigrants rather than Chinese policy. On Vietnam. the President reported the following: Overall. Vietnams emigration policy has liberalized considerably in the last decade and a half. Vietnam has a solid record of cooperation with the United States in permitting Vietnamese to emigrate. Over 500.000 Vietnamese have emigrated as refugees or immigrants to the United States under the Orderly Departure Program (ODP). and only a small number of refugee applicants remain to be processed. The President reported particular progress in the socalled ROVR programthe Resettlement Opportunities for Vietnamese Returnees programformalized in 1997 to facilitate the emigration of Vietnamese who were still in asylum camps in Southeast Asia or who had recently returned to Vietnam. As the President noted in his June 3. 1999 report: After a slow start. processing of eligible cases under the ROVR program accelerated dramatically in 1998 and is now near completion. As of June 1. 1999. the [Government of Vietnam] had cleared for interview 19.975 individuals. or 96 percent of the ROVR applicants.
Keywords matched
emigrated immigrant refugees emigrants immigrants refugee emigrate emigration visas

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
chinese vietnamese
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Humanitarian

Speaker & context

Speaker
DANIEL MOYNIHAN
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
1999-07-19
Speech ID
1060061551
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →