Mr. President. today. I am proud to cosponsor the Immigrant Childrens Health Improvement Act of 1999. introduced by my good friend and colleague Senator CHAFEE. We are joined by our colleagues Senators MCCAIN. JEFFORDS. and MACK. and by Senator GRAHAM. who has long been a leader on this issue. This bill includes three provisions which are part of the Fairness for Legal Immigrants Act of 1999 . which I introduced. along with Senator GRAHAM. on April 14th of this year. They would restore health coverage to legal immigrantsmostly childrenwhose eligibility for benefits is denied to them by the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996. It is a crucial step we should take. I will continue to work to move forward the broader Fairness for Legal Immigrants Act as well because it contains important provisions to prevent hunger and help the elderly and disabled. The Immigrant Childrens Health Improvement Act would: Permit states to provide Medicaid coverage to all eligible legal immigrant children. permit states to provide Medicaid coverage to all eligible legal immigrant pregnant women. and permit states to provide coverage under the Childrens Health Insurance Program (CHIP) to all eligible legal immigrant children. Note that these provisions are optional. There are no mandates in this bill. It would merely allow states to take common sense steps to aid legal immigrant children. The problem is that under current law. states are not allowed to extend such health care coveragewhich is so important for the development of healthy childrento families who have come to the U.S. after August 22. 1996. until the families have been here for five years. Five years is a very long time in the life of a child. Such a bar makes little sense for them. and is nonsensical for pregnant women. It is common knowledge that access to health care is essential for early childhood development. We should. at a minimum. permit states to extend coverage to all poor legal immigrant children. no matter when they have arrived here. Let me emphasize that under the 1996 law. states cannot use federal funds for thisand we are restoring this option to them. This builds upon our recent achievements in promoting health care for childrenlegal immigrant children should not be neglected in these efforts. The provisions of that 1996 law concerning legal immigrants were based on the false premise that immigrants are a financial burden to American taxpayers. On the contrary. A recent comprehensive study by the National Academy of Sciences concluded that immigration actually benefits the U.S. economy. In fact. the study found that the average legal immigrant contributes $1.800 more in taxes than he or she receives in government benefits. Many Americans may not realize this. but legal immigrants pay income and payroll taxes. And without continued legal immigration. the longterm financial condition of Social Security and Medicare would be worsened. According to the most recent Social Security trustees report. a decline in net immigration of 150.000 per year will reduce payroll tax revenues and require a 0.1% payroll tax increase to replace. It is in our interest to see that these immigrant families have healthy children. And it is not merely wise. it is just. These immigrants have come here under the rules we have established and they have abided by those rules. The 1996 law did grevious harm to the safety net for immigrants. Some states have begun their own effortswithout federal fundingto assist immigrants to make up the difference. Yet a new Urban Institute study concluded that "[d]espite the federal benefit restorations and the many states that have chosen to assist immigrants. the social safety net for immigrants remains weaker than before welfare reform and noncitizens generally have less access to assistance than citizens." The Urban study also notes that "[b]y barring many immigrants from federal assistance. the federal government shifted costs to states. many of which already bore a fiscal burden for providing assistance to immigrants." We in Washington should do our fair share. Mr. President. simple decency requires us to continue to provide a measure of a safety net to legal immigrant families. I urge the enactment of this legislation to ensure that we do so. By Mr.
Identified stereotypes
Immigrants are a financial burden to American taxpayers (false premise).