Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030217686

We have not seen that kind of leadership from this administration on this issue. and until we do. this Senator has no choice but to oppose the use of United States military force in Haiti. I would like now to address this subject of making the specific case for war in Haiti. I assume that one of the reasons offered in justification of an invasion of Haiti will be the need to stop illegal immigration from Haiti. I have an abiding interest in this issue. arising from my position as ranking member on the Immigration Subcommittee. I want to specifically address Haitian illegal immigration. and that problemand it is a problemas a justification for an invasion of that tiny country. Illegal immigration from Haiti is indeed a problem. but it is a small problem compared to illegal immigration to this country from Cuba. from China. from Mexico. and from other Central American countries including the Dominican Republic which shares with Haiti the island of Hispaniola. No one is suggesting that we invade any of those countries to stop illegal immigration. and in my view. it is pretty difficult to justify an invasion of Haiti on that basis. Justification for an invasion aside. we do not need to invade Haiti to deter illegal immigration from that country. We have had a. number of Caribbean nations offer their territory for "holding centers" for Haitian illegal immigrantsplaces where persons leaving Haiti could stay until they felt it was safe to return to their country. I assume those offers of locations for holding centers are still open. and establishing holding centers to provide temporary safe haven to the Haitians outside the United States. is the solution to illegal immigration from Haiti. We do not need an invasion. Experience has shown us rather clearly that if we do not allow illegal boat people. whether they be from Haiti. or from Cuba. to enter the United States. no matter what their claim to safe haven may be. the boat flow will dry up. All we need to do is by our words. and by our actions. clearly establish the policy that attempting to enter the United States without proper authority will not give boat people an opportunity to live in the United States until his or her claim for asylum is determined. However. if potential illegal immigrants do not believe we mean it when we say they cannot come. and the Clinton administrations remarkable confusion on the issue has given them good reason not to believe us. they will continue to try to come. The answer to illegal immigration from Haiti is not an invasion. but a clear. firm. consistent. and persevering policy which does not permit the entry into the United States of persons attempting to come on vessels without proper immigration documents. I would close. therefore. by reiterating the point that a convincing case for invasion has not yet been made. and certainly not with respect to resolving problems of illegal immigration. Until and unless other convincing justifications arise. this Senator must continue to oppose risking American lives in a military invasion of Haiti. I ask that an article by Charles Krauthammer. "To Die for Aristide?". be printed in the RECORD.
Keywords matched
Immigration immigration illegal immigrants illegal immigrantsplaces Illegal immigration illegal immigration

Classification

Also mentioned
Cubans Chinese Mexicans Central Americans Dominicans
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALAN SIMPSON
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
WY
Gender
M
Date
1994-09-12
Speech ID
1030217686
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →