Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030206198

Mr. President. I rise to speak concerning this amendment which would appropriate $100 million to reimburse states for the cost of educating immigrants. The money would be distributed under the Emergency Immigration Education Act of 1984. This amendment and the underlying Emergency Immigration Education Act do not differentiate between legal and illegal immigrants. which very much concerns me. The Commission on Immigration Reform recently issued an excellent interim report making recommendations to the administration and the Congress on a variety of immigration issues. including that of providing Federal financial aids to the States for the costs of immigration. The Commission recommended a "shortterm authorization of financial aid to offset at least a portion of certain identifiable costs to states and localities resulting from unlawful immigration." I have seen no solid evidence that it is even possible to accurately identify either the number or cost of illegal immigrants. One reason for this is thatbelieve it or notmany State and local government agencies are prohibited by law. ordinance or rule from even "communicating" with the Immigration and Naturalization Service. The Commission on Immigration Reform recommended that if there is to be such Federal reimbursement to State and local governments that there also be "a requirement that the state and local governments cooperate with Federal authorities to enforce the immigration laws of the United States." If this appropriation were to reimburse impacted States for the cost of educating illegal alien children. then taking $100 million from other programs to fund this amendment might well be justifiedif those costs can be identified. However. since many State and local governments prohibit their officials from communicating with the Immigration Service. I do not know how they can identify those costs attributable to illegal immigration. Cooperation with the INS should be a condition of any such amendment. If this appropriation is to reimburse States for the costs of educating legal immigrant children. then this amendment is not the proper approach to reduce those costs. If legal immigration is so high it is placing an unreasonable financial burden on the States. the answer is to reduce immigration. rather than provide Federal reimbursement. Also. States could rethink some of their very expensive bilingual education programs. It has been the policy of the United States for more than 100 years that newcomers should "pay their way" after immigrating to the United States. Personally. I believe that legal immigrants do pay their way. and that the impacted States probably benefit from legal immigrants. if they are coming in reasonable numbers. Some studies have found that legal immigrants more than pay their way. although there have also been contradictory studies. If the numbers are unreasonable. and if immigrants are causing a burden the states cannot bear. then we should be discussing reducing admissions until the economies of the impacted states have had an opportunity to recover.
Keywords matched
immigrant immigration Immigration illegal alien illegal immigrants immigrants Naturalization immigrating illegal immigration

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
legal immigrants illegal immigrants
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALAN SIMPSON
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
WY
Gender
M
Date
1994-08-08
Speech ID
1030206198
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →