Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030206084

This is an increase. of $11 million from the 1994 level. But it still equals only $62 per eligible student. far less than the over $1.000 per student which local and State funds are required to be spent in terms of incremental costs. The amendment that Senator HUTCHISON and I are offering. would transfer $100 million from salary expenses and program management to the Emergency Immigrant Education Act. This has been endorsed by the National School Boards Association. the National Conference of Mayors. and the National Council of State Legislatures. I recognize that many administrative accounts in this bill have already been frozen or reduced. However. our States are facing an emergency situation. one which requires us to make tough choices about how we will spend our Federal funds. For the past 10 years. the Federal Government has avoided these tough choices because it has had little incentive to provide adequate assistance to the States for immigrant education services. Whether or not we provide adequate funds to reimburse States for the costs of educating immigrant students. States will continue to provide these services and will continue to have to pay the tab and will continue to have to dilute the quality of education to all of the children in their school districts. The Senator from Iowa has argued that the EIEA Program primarily benefits only five States. That is because there are currently five States facing emergency immigration situations. We have had other examples of emergencies: in my State with the hurricanes. in the State of the Senator from Iowa with floods. and the State of the Senator from California with earthquakes and otherwise. This Congress has not refused to recognize an emergency just because it was highly concentrated in its impact. I believe. Mr. President. that similarly we should answer the question: Should we abandon those communities of America which are heavily impacted by immigration? The answer is clearly no. But in this situation. when our States are overwhelmed by the impact of Federal immigration policy. a policy which has failed to protect our borders. failed to enforce our immigration laws. and has allowed hundreds of thousands of undocumented aliens into our country. and our States have repeatedly asked the Federal Government for assistance to deal with this problem. we have the responsibility to provide that assistance. The Senator from Iowa has also argued that the number of immigrant students has decreased over the past year. However. that has not changed the fact that the EIEA Program has never been adequately funded. and currently reimburses States for only a minuscule percentage of their cost of educating immigrant children. The Federal Government has the complete constitutional responsibility for our Nations immigration policies as enumerated in article I. section 8 of the U.S. Constitution. The power and singular responsibility was conferred from the States to the FedIeral Government to "establish a uniform rule of naturalization." When there is an egregious failure of the Federal Government to carry out their responsibility. the community in which this failure is projected should not have to pay the cost. Until the Federal Government is required to meet its responsibility for its dereliction in its duty to protect the borders and enforce immigration. then the Federal Government has no basis upon which to refuse to provide assistance to those States which have been heavily impacted. States and localities do not have the luxury of avoiding this responsibility. I urge my colleagues to join with the cosponsors of this amendment in support of the proposition that the Federal Government should meet its obligations and should assure that the goal of providing equal educational opportunities for all children in all communities of America is realized.
Keywords matched
undocumented immigrant immigration naturalization Immigrant

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Humanitarian

Speaker & context

Speaker
BOB GRAHAM
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
FL
Gender
M
Date
1994-08-08
Speech ID
1030206084
Paragraph
#3
← Prev Next →