Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030199845

What is the national interest? Well. in Haiti we have only heard three representations of national interest being made. The first is that there was an outflow of refugees of such enormity that we needed to take action as a nation to stop the outflow of refugees. The second was that Haiti was a transit point for drugs. The third was that Haiti had a government that was governed by thugs who have usurped the democratically elected government. Let us go down those three points in order because this administration does not seem to be willing to explain them. Let us at least discuss them. First. on the issue of refugees. yes. there was an outflow of refugees. But why did that occur? It occurred because of American policy. It was a selfinflicted event. The administration changed our policy on refugees relative to Haiti about 4 weeks ago. and they said. "All right. We will let people from Haiti come to the United States and find political asylum here in a much broader context than we have been willing to do in the past." As a result. that word got out in Haiti. and thousands of people attempted to leave the island. The administration quickly saw the error of its ways. and said. "Well. we made a mistake in making that representation. We will not accept refugees from Haiti." As a result. that word got back out. and now we see that the refugee situation. the departure of citizens from Haiti. has dropped off dramatically. So the outflow of refugees was not an event which required military force to correct. It was a political event which was selfinflicted. which required the reinstatement of an intelligent political philosophy or position and we have corrected it as a result of that. In any event. it would be very hard to justify the use of American military force to stifle the illegal immigration problem from Haiti in the context of the Western Hemisphere. because the Haitian illegal immigrant problem to the United States is basically insignificant compared to the illegal immigration problem we have in some of our other sister States in this hemisphere. The number of illegal immigrants coming out of Haiti this year is less than 20.000. The number coming out of Mexico this year. to date. is somewhere close to 750.000. So if we are going to be invading Haiti for the purposes of stopping illegal immigrants. are we also going to invade other sister states in the hemisphere who create a much more significant problem for us? I do not think so. I do not think we can rationalize the policy on that basis.
Keywords matched
refugees illegal immigrants refugee illegal immigrant illegal immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
JUDD GREGG
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
NH
Gender
M
Date
1994-07-28
Speech ID
1030199845
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →