Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030189168

They have changed very dramatically. They have served. in my view. to confuse our allies and to encourage our adversaries. As we all know. the first policy was that of candidate Clinton who said: "I am appalled by the decision of the Bush administration to pick up fleeing Haitians on the high seas and forcibly return them to Haiti." The second policy was after President Clinton became President and he basically. after becoming aware of the hundreds of boats that were being built all over Haiti to bring refugees from Haiti to Florida on Inauguration Day. basically announced a policy identical to the Bush policy. The third policy. and frankly the most disturbing one to me. Mr. President. is policy by hunger strike. After a hunger strike by an individual and pressures from the Congressional Black Caucus. the new policy proposed to process refugees on ships off the coast and in third countries. The new policy took effect on June 16. 1994. and then began a new flood of refugees. exactly what we sought to avoid. Between June 16. when the policy changed. and July 7. roughly 14.000 Haitians were picked up at sea. That is a massive number. and. of course. one that would not be sustainable. We just could not at that level of refugees continue to find sufficient safe havens in order to accommodate them. The fourth policy came this last Tuesday. This was a policy once again designed to stem the flow of refugees. And the policy was that refugees would be taken to outofcountry processing centers. If they were found to have a legitimate claim of persecution. they would be allowed to stay in the refugee camp. If not. they would be returned to Haiti. This was backed up by statements from the administration such as the special envoy on this issue. Mr. William Gray. who said: "Those who take to the boats will not have resettlement possibilities in the United States." One day later. apparently under pressure from the Congressional Black Caucus and others. a tougher policy designed to stem the flow was overturned for what could only be viewed as political reasons. Refugees would not have to prove a fear of persecution to stay in the third country refugee camps. Mr. President. hopefully. a bipartisan commission could come up with a consistent policy as regards Haiti.
Keywords matched
refugees Refugees refugee

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JOHN MCCAIN
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
AZ
Gender
M
Date
1994-07-13
Speech ID
1030189168
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →