Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030181826

We do know from history. however. that the last time we said we were going to go into Haiti with military force and try to resolve the Haitian political situation through the use of a military action and we expected to spend a few months doing it we ended up there for 19 years. and the overtones from that invasion and that occupation are still fairly significant in not only the Caribbean but throughout South America and especially Central America. The second issue. of course. is what is our national interest in Haiti. In the arguments made I guess most often our national interest in Haiti and the one that has the most legitimacy is to keep Haitian refugees from coming to the United States. In addition. of course. we have the national interest of seeing the horrible situation Haitian people are confronting resolved in some manner so that they can go on with reasonably organized or orderly lifestyles and not be subject to a government that is basically one of violence and vigilante law. Those are the two arguments that are made for our national interest. but I think we need to look at them in some depth because they have not been made substantively to the American people in the way the American people can say. yes. that legitimizes our putting an American life at risk. On the first issue. the issue of immigration. that to a large degree has been created by ourselves through our use of sanctions. We are the ones who have put sanctions on this nation to a point where the only people benefiting from the sanctions are the political thugs who are running the country and the people on the streets are the ones who are suffering those sanctions to the degree where their only option appears to be to sail in small boats and hope wherever they come ashore will be better than where they left. And that was our doing in large part by the use of sanctions which may have been put on with good intention but clearly have not worked and have had. in fact. unintended consequences that have significantly deteriorated the situation and generated. in fact. the immigration. the outpouring of people from Haiti. And so I do not think we have many excuses in the area of the excessive outflow of people. the immigration into the United States of Haitians. We do not need to look much farther than ourselves to find a cause for that action that presently is occurring. and it is occurring in this case because we changed our policy relative to dealing with the people once we met them on the high seas. At least for a while we were saying to these people. "Im sorry.
Keywords matched
refugees immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JUDD GREGG
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
NH
Gender
M
Date
1994-06-27
Speech ID
1030181826
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →