Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030173878

The recipients of many of these benefits are often the poorest and most downtrodden of our society. It is manifestly unjust for the Government of the United States not to protect and care for the citizens of the United States. I find it interesting that many of those opposed to reforming our immigration laws argue that this Nation has historically been able to absorb large waves of immigration. This may be true. But they forget to point out that almost all of the benefits and services available today were not available during many of the earlier waves of immigration. There are other more unfortunate costs that States must bear for our failed immigration policies. Those are the costs of incarcerating criminals who are not lawfully within the country. According to the California Department of Corrections. there will be some 18.000 undocumented individuals in their personsthe California State prisonsnext year. The annual cost of keeping one inmate in prison in the State of California is almost $21.000 a year. The bottom line is that the State of California. on this one aspect of their burden. is having to spend $375 million a year on a responsibility that fairly and realistically should be borne by the Federal Government. California is not alone in dealing with the growing number of undocumented criminals residing in our prisons. Texas and Florida are also saddled with enormous costs. and their prisons too are overcrowded with undocumented criminals. In Texas. Governor Richards office estimated it costs the State and local governments almost $56 million just to incarcerate criminals who are not lawfully within the country. That is only for the State of Texas. In Florida. the Immigration and Naturalization Service continually releases asylum claimants before their asylum status or criminal history is even checked. Keep in mind that in discussing the costs and burdens placed on the States for incarcerating these individuals we are not even counting the cost that society pays for the transgressions committed. The States are not the only victims. U.S. citizens and those individuals in this country lawfully are being twice victimized by this phenomenon. first. by the crimes committed against them. and. second. when their tax dollars are being used in apprehending. trying and imprisoning criminals who. but for the failure of our current laws. should not have been here in the first place. What has been the Federal Governments response? Sadly. the crime bills contain language calling for Federal reimbursement for the incarceration costsif we provide the money. which we probably will not door. in the alternative. that the Federal Government take custody of undocumented criminals. The taxpayers are paying for this whether they are taxpayers of the State of Texas. California.
Identified stereotypes
Generalizes undocumented immigrants as criminals.
Keywords matched
undocumented Immigration immigration asylum status Naturalization asylum claimants

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Criminal Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
HARRY REID
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
NV
Gender
M
Date
1994-06-14
Speech ID
1030173878
Paragraph
#7
← Prev Next →