Goss contention that lie de Gonave could become a foothold for President Aristides return is disingenuous. The island is isolated from the Haitian mainland. has no infrastructure. would pose a serious problem regarding communicating with the rest of Haiti. This provisions in the amendment would only serve to add to the political uncertainty and repression in Haiti. which. in turn. would lead to even greater refugee outflows. This amendment violates international and U.S. law which prohibit the forcible return of persons fleeing persecution to the country of such persecution since Ile do Gonave is Haitian territory. and Haitians are fleeing the most brutal government in the western hemisphere. Gosu argued that the amendment would lift the current sanctions on Haiti.