I spoke about the crisis in Haiti and the lack of focus of Americas policy. Although the President has finally addressed Haiti. his new policy is poorly thought out. hopelessly inconsistent and very shortsighted. It lacks a longterm strategy for resolving the opposing extremist positions in Haiti. but worse. it contains an explosive combination of tighter sanctions and looser asylum procedures likely to spark a new burst of Haitian refugees headed for Florida. Its simple logic: A tougher embargo equals more economic hardship among Haitis most desperate poor. More economic hardship equals more refugees. The President said he "hopes" we wont see a flood of refugees--but history suggests that hope is unfounded. The Presidents own advisers reaffirm that most people leaving Haiti are economic refugeesnot political asylum seekers fleeing for their lives. A New York Times story this week emphasizes a "deeply held view in the administration that most of those seeking political asylum are economic migrants posing as victims of persecution" Officials at the U.S. Embassy in Haiti conclude that "The Haitian left. including President Aristide and his supporters in Washington and here. consistently manipulate or even fabricate human rights abuses as a propaganda tool." The Presidents Deputy National Security Adviser. Sandy Berger. said "Only about 5 percent of those people who have come into the processing centers are. in fact. political refugees." When Haitian refugees have landed in third countries. presumably safe from political persecution. most have sought to return to Haiti. Of course. there is no denying the brutality of the thugs now in control in Haitiwe know there has been repression and political persecution. But tighter sanctions will not resolve this crisis. rather. as the President himself has said. they will. "Cause more hardships for innocent Haitians." The President said the Haitian military will "bear full responsibility for this action." but I am not sure they agree or care. My fear is that. even after tougher sanctions take hold. we will have further demoralized the Haitian people. the thugs will still be in powerand we will have done nothing to help Haitians rebuild their democracy. What we will have done is encouraged more Haitians to overload leaky boats in sharkinfested waters. Despite the Clinton administrations claim that economic refugees will be more quickly processed and then repatriated. in the past several weeks approximately 500 Haitians arrived in Florida and were released into our country as a humanitarian exceptionincluding 13 who tested positive for HIV. These actions speak louder than the Presidents words. Floridas Democrat Governor. Lawton Chiles. recognizes the potential problemhe expects 5.000 to 10.000 refugees a month as a result of this new policy. In his words. "This decision will result in additional burdens on State and local governments in Florida * * * Florida alone cannot shoulder the tremendous burdens that result from Federal immigration policy." Governor Chiles has filed a lawsuit against the Federal Government. seeking to recoup hundreds of millions of dollars the State has spent on illegals in Florida. Mr. Speaker. there is a better way for Haiti that solves the refugee problem. solves the Aristide problem and begins to solve the longterm democracy problemwe can establish a safe haven on the fle De La Gonave. a small island about 15 miles off the coast of Haiti. The United States could expand its processing of asylum seekers on this Haitian island. safe from the fear of violence. President Aristidethe popularly elected and rightful President of Haiticould go there and begin to rebuild his government in Haiti. This plan obviates the need for an elaborate and ineffective plan to screen refugees aboard U.S. ships and it would remove the powerful Miami magnet. Florida is anything but a closed doorthousands of refugees from all over this hemisphere have made their home there under orderly immigration processing and are productive. hardworking members of our society. But Florida cannot throw her doors wide open to all refugees from any nation who seek a better life in the United Statesthat kind of disorder stretches our resources beyond their limits. I urge the administration to review my plan. It can work today to meet the longterm interests of Haiti and the United States.
Keywords matched
refugeesnot immigration refugees refugee asylum seekers migrants