Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030155362

Mr. President. as the year progresses. the debate over immigration policy grows more and more heated. Calls for restrictions on immigrationboth legal and illegalare accompanied by claims that immigrants represent a drain on our economy and a threat to American values. These sentiments manifest themselves in immigrationrelated amendments that are being offered to virtually every bill that reaches the Senate floor. More often than not. however. the debate over immigration policy seems driven not by reason. but by emotion. Facts take a backseat to impressions. and these impressions are often misguided. If we are to undertake to reform our immigration lawsand I do not deny that these laws are in need of some reformwe must understand the facts of our current immigration regime. and withstand the desire to rely on empty rhetoric. I am not alone in my views. Recently the Washington Timesin an article entitled "Immigration Facts and Fiction." written by my friend Ben Wattenbergcounseled Americans to find and understand the facts underlying our current immigration system before undertaking a comprehensive reform of that system. The Times article. citing a recently published study by the Urban Institute on the costs of immigration. noted several important facts that should bear on any attempted immigration reform: The majority of illegal entrants into the United States are individuals who overstay their visas. not individuals who illegally cross our borders. Legal immigrants use less welfare per capita than nativeborn Americans. Annual taxes paid by immigrants to all levels of Government more than offset the cost of services received by these immigrants. generating a net annual surplus of $25 to $30 billion. Legal immigrants do not adversely affect the employment rate. Rather. the jobs created by immigrant employers for nativeborn Americans offset the jobs taken by legal immigrants from nativeborn Americans. While the total number of foreignborn people in the United States is greater than at any time in our history. the percentage of foreignborn in the United States is only 8 percent. compared to 15 percent a century ago. These factsnot our fears and impressionsshould inform the immigration debate. Only then can we determine what is necessary. and avoid what is harmful both to immigrants and to our national identity and traditions. I ask unanimous consent that the Washington Times article entitled "Immigration Facts and Fiction" by Ben Wattenberg be inserted into the RECORD.
Keywords matched
immigrant Immigration immigrationboth immigration immigrants immigrationrelated visas

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
PAUL SIMON
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
IL
Gender
M
Date
1994-04-20
Speech ID
1030155362
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →