Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030152157

Pennsylvania. and Washington. At an annual cost of $18.000 or more per prisoner. this translates to a yearly financial burden of between $420 and $615 million on the criminal justice systems of affected communities. These costs. which are increasing rapidly. are the result of the Federal Governments failure to enforce our Immigration lawsa failure which has resulted in the unlawful entry Into the United States of millions of illegal immigrants. In Los Angeles County alone. the cost of incarcerating deportable aliens is $34 million per year. If the cost of prosecutors. public defenders. and probation officers is included. the overall cost of deportable criminal aliens to the countys criminal justice system amounts to $75 million per year. The impact of convicted criminal aliens on Los Angeles County was documented in two studies conducled in 1990 and 1992 by the countywide Criminal Justice Coordination Committee in conjunction with the County Sheriff and the Immigration and Naturalization Service [INS]. Those reports estimated that 19 percent of the inmates in Los Angeles County jails were foreign born and 11 percent were deportable aliens. They found that over 23.000 deportable aliens go through the Los Angeles County justice system each year. Furthermore. as the 1992 report stated. "significant numbers of deportable aliens who are removed from the country do. in fact. return to Los Angeles County and sustain new contacts with the criminal justice system." The study found that 40 percent of the 1.875 deportable aliens who were released from the county jail in May 1990 were rearrested an average of two times in the following 12 months. Only 339 of the 1.875less than onefifthof those deportable aliens had no previous or subsequent arrests. The other 1.536 had been arrested an average of seven times. for a combined total of 10.989 arrests. since they arrived in the United States. Yet. while State and local governments have the responsibility for incarcerating criminal aliens and processing their cases. they have no jurisdiction. obviously. over the enforcement of immigration laws. no authority to deport aliens who are convicted of crimes. and no authority to ensure that those deported are not permitted to reenter the country. Congress recognized the unfairness of this situation in the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act [IRCA]. and acknowledged the Federal Governments responsibility for the criminal alien population. Section 501 of the act specilically authorizes the reimbursement to States of costs incurred in the imprisonment of illegal aliens. Unfortunately. however. this commitment has yet to be fulfilled. because Congress has failed to appropriate any funding for that purpose. Currently. the Governors of several States are seeking relief from this predicament by requestingor even suingthe Federal Government to take custody of thousands of illegal aliens housed in their prisons. I expect that more demands of this kind are likely to be forthcoming from States and localities with large criminal alien populations as these communities attempt to cope with the strain that the Federal Governments failed immigration policy places on their budgets. And I believe that those demands are fully justified. This amendment will ensure that the Federal Government lives up to its financial obligations under the Immigration Reform and Control Act. Our amendment allows Congress and the administration 4 more years to pay for the incarceration of criminal aliens through the appropriations process. if that does not happen. then. beginning October 1. 1998. this amendment will force the Federal Government to pay for if. Knowing that the Federal Government will soon be required to assume this burden will. we hope. also encourage the administration. and the Congress. to take strong steps to stop illegal immigration altogether. so that potential criminal aliens will not be able to enter our country in the first place. Mr. Chairman. some Members may argue against this amendment because it technically creates a new entitlement beginning in fiscal 1999. which is a violation of the Budget Act.
Identified stereotypes
Generalization about rearrest rates of deportable aliens.
Keywords matched
foreign born deportable Immigration illegal immigrants immigration deported Naturalization illegal immigration illegal aliens

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Criminal Legal / procedural Security threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
ANTHONY BEILENSON
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
CA
Gender
M
Date
1994-04-12
Speech ID
1030152157
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →