Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030151397

The United States cannot do it alone. In addition to the implementation of sanctions. this bill urges the President to take whatever steps necessary to support the admission of United Nations and/or Organization of American States human rights observers to Haiti. This bill calls upon the President to support an effective multinational border patrol to monitor the border between Haiti and the Dominican Republic to ensure that there are no leaks across the border. The purpose of these measures--and what the crux of United States policy should beis to isolate and pressure the ruthless military regime in Haiti. and pave the way for the return of Haitis elected President. This bill also reaffirms the United States commitment to support multilateral socioeconomic and peacekeeping assistance to Haiti upon President Aristides return. Finally. one of most disturbing aspects of this crisis relates to the Haitian refugees. When I came to the Senate and was appointed to its Foreign Relations Committee 1 year ago. one of the first issues which confronted me was the admission of Haitian refugees into the United States. I agreed with President Clintons campaign promise to show a more humanitarian and supportive attitude. and to assist those who were fleeing "a wellfounded fear of persecution" in a repressive regime. Now. 1 year later. this humane policy has evaporated. Thousands of Haitians still sail to our shores in the hope of escaping the oppressive government of their homeland only to be picked up by the United States military. at sea. and returned to Haiti and General Cedras. We say we want Haiti to be democratic. yet wethe country that is supposed to be the shining example of democracysend them back to a military regime that tortures. starves. rapes. and even murders its own people. This practice also demonstrates a glaring inconsistency in the refugee policy of the United States. The blanket rejection of Haitian refugees into this country smacks of racism. as the Congressional Black Caucus recently charged. Others. such as Russians and Cubans. are welcomed into this country with open arms while the Haitians are sent home. Boats carrying hundreds of Haitian refugees are interdicted at sea by the United States Coast Guard before they ever reach United States waters and are sent back home without so much as an informal hearing to determine if they qualify for refugee statusthat is. "fleeing a wellfounded fear of persecution." According to one Defense Department official who spoke at the recent hearings. the Coast Guard "interdicted 16 Haitian vessels with 853 migrants during fiscal year 1994. During the month of February. a total of 345 immigrants were interdicted." This example illustrates what Dr. Koh referred to as Americas dont ask policy regarding Haitian immigrants--they are turned away before we even ask them why they have come. This bill will put an end to this outrageous practice. First of all. this bill will bring the United States in compliance with international law. and direct authorities to assess each refugees situation individually to determine whether or not they qualify for asylum. At the same time. the bill requires the United States to refuse refugee status to any Haitian serving in or receiving support from the military or to anyone who has violated United Nations resolutions. Instead of the current deplorable practice of automatic repatriation. Senator DODDS bill requires that Haitian refugees be granted temporary protected status by the United States Government. In the past. we have extended this status to refugees from countries such as Kuwait. Somalia. El Salvador. and Bosnia. This would allow these people a safe haven until democracy is restored in their country. They would be in our protection until President Aristide has been successfully returned to office and the military leaders have been removed. Representative CARRIE MEEK has introduced a bill with similar provisions. the Haitian Refugee Fairness Act in the House. which currently has 65 cosponsors. According to Representative MEEK. this bill will "bring the treatment of Haitian refugees by the United States Government into conformity with international law and make the treatment that Haitian refugees receive from the United States Government consistent with the treatment given to refugees from other nations." Both these bills propose what is fair and what should have been done from the beginning. By sending Haitian refugees back to the oppressive government from which they are fleeing without first determining if there is significant risk to them in their own country is in violation of international law. We must act to correct this policy before we send thousands more Haitians back to perilous lives under tyrannical rule. Another procedure that must be reformed is the current incountry processing that is used when Haitians want to leave their country.
Identified stereotypes
Haitian refugees are being unfairly rejected compared to other groups like Russians and Cubans.
Keywords matched
refugees immigrants Refugee refugee border patrol migrants temporary protected status

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Russians Cubans Kuwaitis Somalis Salvadorans Bosnians
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural Victim

Speaker & context

Speaker
RUSSELL FEINGOLD
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
WI
Gender
M
Date
1994-03-25
Speech ID
1030151397
Paragraph
#4
← Prev Next →