Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030148370

We were shown thousands and thousands of forged documents that smugglers use to get people into the country. I have worked to ensure that smugglers and document forgers know that stiff penalties await them. My amendment to increase the civil and criminal penalties for forgery of immigration documents was successfully included in the Senate crime bill. While we act now to stop illegal immigration. we must address the fact that years of inadequate enforcement has already allowed millions of people to enter the country illegally. placing a burden on the resources of State and local governments. Last week. I successfully included language in the Budget Resolution Act that establishes the principle of Federal responsibility to reimburse State and local costs. It is the sole responsibility of the Federal government to set and enforce immigration policy. and the Federal Government must reimburse States for the cost of their failure to enforce that policy. But when we go to the Federal Government for reimbursements. our request must be based on solid figures. That is why I have asked the General Accounting Office to analyze recent cost and benefit estimates and assess the net fiscal impact of illegal immigrants in State like California. In addition to these measures that I have securedstronger border enforcement. increased penalties for document forgery. and steps towards Federal reimbursement for costs to State and local governments--I am a cosponsor of bills by Senators KENNEDY and GRAHAM that address asylum reform and the high cost of incarcerating criminal aliens. But these critical reform measures are only part of a balan. i approach. Today. I offer legislation that addresses three additional areas that are essentil to repairing our system: labor law enforcement. oversight of the border pE.trol. and integration of legal immigrants into American society through uitizenship. Mr. President. illegal immigrants themselves are often those most hurt by the breakdown of our system. The primary reason that people cross our border illegally is to find work. and most doat substandard wages and in dangerous conditions. Our current efforts to prevent the hiring and exploitation of undocumented workers have been inadequate and ineffective. In 1986. sanctions against employers who knowingly hired illegal immigrants were passed as part of the Immigration Reform and Control Act. However. illegal immigration continues at high rate. After an initial drop following the implementation of employer sanctions. Border Patrol apprehension rates have resurged. climbing back up to 1.16 million a year. Employer sanctions have failed to reduce the job magnet and the flow of illegal immigrants into our country continues. Our second line of attack against the job magnetenforcement of labor law standards by the Labor Department has also failed to curb exploitation. Despite continued problems with illegal immigration and labor exploitation. the staff at the Department of Labor dedicated to investigating labor law violations has plummeted over the last decade from 1.100 employees in 1980. down to 817 in 1993. The regional office in San Francisco. which has the job of covering violations throughout Californiathe destination for over half of the illegal immigrants in the United States--is only equipped with 89 investigators. Subsequently. as of July 1993. they faced a backlog of over 1.300 cases in the California area. It is amazing that there are only 16 employees struggling with the task of investigating labor law violations in the large five county Los Angeles area. If we do not address the job magnet and the system of cruel exploitation that fuels illegal immigration our borders and airports will never be secure. Document forgers and smugglers will continue to undermine our system. and people will continue to come to the United States illegally. straining local resources. But we need to find innovative. cost effective approaches to confront this problem instead of focusing all our resources into efforts that have not shown strong results.
Keywords matched
undocumented immigration Immigration illegal immigrants immigrants border enforcement Border Patrol illegal immigration

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural Victim

Speaker & context

Speaker
BARBARA BOXER
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
CA
Gender
F
Date
1994-03-23
Speech ID
1030148370
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →