Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030144128

Madam Chairman. I move to strike the last word. Madam Chairman. this amendment is counterproductive. shortsighted. and an unconstitutional attempt to build upon antiimmigrant sentiment. Not only does the amendment deprive children of receiving an education. but it is also an unfunded Federal mandate that places a huge financial burden on every local school in every district in this Nation. Local schools would be forced to investigate the immigration status of its students and their parents without receiving any money from the Federal Government. In short. this amendment harms schools. and sends the message to some children that they are different and not good enough to receive the same education as other children who. for some reason. are considered better than they are. As proposed. this amendment would expose innocent individuals who are U.S. citizens or otherwise legally admitted into this country to widespread discrimination. It is likely that only those who look different than someone like Mr. RORRABACHER will be asked by untrained school officials to produce proof of citizenship when they are detained or questioned. In fact. innocent individuals have been mistakenly deported. and under this amendment. cases of mistaken identity will be enormously increased. This amendment will force teachers to single out and discriminate against students in order to receive the funds they desperately need. Furthermore. school administrators and teachers who are already overwhelmed with the educational system would have to enforce complex immigration laws. As an unfunded Federal mandate. this amendment would place unreasonable administrative and costly burdens on every district in this country including those with little immigration. The fact is that this amendment will not prevent illegal immigration. Instead. the result will be a country where children will grow up poorly educated and will be unable to compete in a global economy. The amendment also forces Federal. State. and local Jurisdictions to act against the principles of our constitution. The Supreme Court has ruled that all children are allowed access to public education. More importantly. the Court determined that children of undocumented individuals eventually acquire legal status. Therefore. if these children are denied an education. we will be creating an underclass of individuals who will be illprepared to take on their roles as future workers and contributors to society. Madam Chairman. school boards as well as the Immigration and Naturalization Service oppose this amendment. They do so because they understand that our focus needs to be on the enhancement of our educational system for all children. By discriminating against our children and by adding more burdens and costs to our local schools. we would be harming all Americans.
Identified stereotypes
Generalization that children of undocumented immigrants will be poorly educated and unable to compete in a global economy.
Keywords matched
undocumented deported immigration Immigration Naturalization illegal immigration antiimmigrant

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
WILLIAM RICHARDSON
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
NM
Gender
M
Date
1994-03-16
Speech ID
1030144128
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →