Session #101 · 1989–91

Speech #1010014525

With the chasm that divides what we have. With the chasm that divides the worlds rich from its poor growing wider and deeper. this may be the genesis of the new policies of restrictionim. an attempt to bar those other masses. But this approach ignores the fact that governments are specifically obligated by international covenant to deal with refugees and asylum seekers differently from other migrants. To avoid this. some have asserted that refugees are not refugees at all. but rather are economically motivated. simply trying to join us because of what we have. We dont have the moral right to underestimate refugee pain. We have the moral obligation to consider their fears with ungerrymandered criteria and to respond generously. The moral wrong is the risk of rebuffing. to our later shame. deserving individuals and undermining. perhaps for years to come. the international refugee protection system. one of the most humanitarian systems the international community has yet constructed. As usual. 1988 was a year of pluses and minuses for refugees. The most dramatic event early in the year was the action taken by Thailand to crack down on Vietnamese boat people. Beginning in late January. an interdiction blockade in the Gulf of Thailand deflected and redirected refugee boats headed to Thailand. Many boats were pushed back as they sought to land. In the process. several hundred refugees died. The changed psychology of the situation spawned a dramatic increase in pirate attacks against refugees. During the following months. attitudes in other first asylum countries of the region hardened. Pushbacks continued in Indonesia. Hong Kong rushed to implement a new screening program as a deterrent. Malaysia announced its intention to close its major refugee camp. That these developments were tragic for individual Vietnamese refugees cannot be minimized. The events did. however. trigger movement towards a fundamental reassessment of the refugee situation in the region. including calls for a new international conference on the matter. It will be crucial in 1989 for the international community to resist pressures to wash its hands of the continuing exodus from Vietnam and to construct a truly principled approach that employees the full range of humanitarian solutions for these refugeesone that. while achieving improved control and minimizing less compelling flight. also fully protects refugees. Thailand has unfortunately also allowed the deterioration of the screening program for refugees from Laos that It implemented in 1985. As a result. Hmong in particular continue to be pushed back into Laos. The U.S. quietly began to reconsider for resettlement some previously rejected Cambodians at Khao I Dang. a welcome change. Thailand made several important improvements in life quality and security for Cambodians located along the ThailandCambodians border. but inaction by Thailand and the international community permitted the dread Khmer Rouge to force thousands of refugees back into Cambodia. Finally. Thailand. which for years has provided unoffical haven for ethnic Karen and others who have fled fighting in Burma. also recieved a substantial number of students who fled political upheaval in most of Burmas major cities. Unfortunately. Thailand has not permitted UNHCR to fulfill its mandate regarding these refugees. Aside from the successful final stages of the repatriation of Ugandan refugees from Sudan. the situation of refugees in Africa deteriorated markedly in 1988. The most predictable event was the continuing exodus from ravished Mozambique. The U.S. State Department released an invaluable report analyzing violence against civilians. attributing the great mass of it to the Renamo forces. Although the refugees have fled to every contiguous country. tiny Malawi has a refugee burden in many ways unmatched by any in the world. The refugee influx is a twelfth of the nations own population. Three other situations in Africa exploded into view in 1988. In August. ethnic violence in northern Burundi killed thousands and forced the flight of more then 50.000 to Rwanda. Conflict in northern Somalia resulted in massive destruction in the major city of Hargeisa. In June. some 350.000 fled into nearby Ethiopia. which itself remains the Horn of Africas largest refugee producer. The situation of the Somali refugees deteriorated in late 1988. resulting in substantial criticism of UNHCR by the nongovernmental organizations providing assistance. The conflict in southern Sudan finally entered the worlds focus. This current phase of the struggle between the Islamic.
Keywords matched
refugeesone migrants refugees asylum seekers refugee

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Vietnamese boat people Hmong Cambodians Karen
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
CLAIBORNE PELL
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
RI
Gender
M
Date
1989-04-12
Speech ID
1010014525
Paragraph
#3
← Prev Next →