Session #101 · 1989–91

Speech #1010014508

As a past chairman of the Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe and a current commissioner. I have fought hard for Soviet compliance with its international human rights obligations. Now that we are finally beginning to see better compliance. especially with the right to freedom of emigration. we are confronted with the problem that we are not ready to deal with it. The result is that we now are getting worse reviews In the international press that the Soviet Union. particularly as a result of our handling of these refugees. Weve created a bureaucratic nightmare. one that is being acted out in full view of the European press. It is hard to picture how we can continue to be a respected and credible critical voice calling the Soviets and their Warsaw Pact allies to account for their lesser. but still significant human rights violations at the forthcoming Paris Human Dimension Helsinki Process meeting. when the people the Soviets release are languishing in a bureaucratic maze that Franz Kafka would have admired. We have to get this mess under control and soon. Our budget deficit will excuse many things. but not this. I applaud the administrations initiative to create a new immigration category and allocate $85 million for the refugee admissions program and $15 million for refugee assistance needs in Africa and Southeast Asia. The additional refugee funding will meet the costs for 28.500 persons. according to administration testimony. raising the fiscal year 1989 total to 112.500 refugees. The difficulty is that this new administration initiative does not solve the problem. As my colleagues know. I have been continuously and severely critical of the Immigration and Naturalization Services shortcomings. They have done too little to improve their performance. which in the case of Soviet refugees. falls far short of the mark. In particular. the problem arises of the application of the statute to the refugees. The pertinent part of the statute states as follows: (Tlhe term refugee means any person who * * * is unable or unwilling to return to [his or her country]. and is unable or unwilling to avail himself or herself of the protection of that country because of persecution or a wellfounded fear of persecution on account of race. religion. nationality. membership in a particular social group. or political opinion * **. (8 U.S.C. 1101(a)(42).) It has been alleged that the INS. fully aware of a recent Supreme Court decision setting forth standards for applying the "persecution or wellfounded fear of persecution" test. is not applying it properly. The effect of this misapplication is to reduce the number of people qualified for admission to the United States as refugees to a number equal to the resources available to pay for them. The administrations new request addresses in part the need for additional resources. but does not address the underlying question of INS conduct. That is a serious issue and one the appropriate oversight committees would do well to explore with thoroughness and speed.
Keywords matched
Immigration emigration Naturalization immigration refugees refugee

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Humanitarian

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALFONSE DAMATO
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
1989-04-12
Speech ID
1010014508
Paragraph
#2
← Prev Next →