Session #101 · 1989–91

Speech #1010006170

We have some Vietnamese who risk their very lives and that of their families In an unseaworthy boat trying to get to Thailand so they can find a brighter economic future in the United States. some Soviets who find that glasnost offers an opportunity to leave the Soviet Union for a freer life in America. and some middleclass Nicaraguans facing 20.000percent inflation in their country who pay a huge sum to a smuggler to get them to America. But those folks are all looking for "a better life" in America. they are not fleeing political persecution at home. They all have advocacy groups here in the United States who are pleading their cases and. in some instances. condemning the Federal officials enforcing the law who are charged with determining whether these peoples meet the definition of "refugee"-that being a person with "a wellfounded fear of persecution based upon race. religion. nationality. membership in a particular social group. or political opinion." The distinction among refugees. asylumees. immigrants. economic migrants. and humanitarian parolees is lost in the clamor as we stubbornly and sentimentally cling to the former definition of refugee-"escapees" from Communist or Communistdominated countries. While the Refugee Act intended the selection of refugees to be ideologically neutral. domestic pressures have resulted in one set of standards for refugee selection being applied in one part of the world. and quite different standards being applied in another. While there is so much pressure to take large numbers of refugees. there is little or no support for private funding and voluntary resettlement of the refugees. as the Federal coffers dry up. So now here we are as of yesterday. with a proposal. S. 489. to take the funding which we appropriated to reimburse States for the costs of providing education and other assistance to newly legalized immigrants. The funds are requested so that we can accept more refugees and fund the transportation. reception and resettlement costs of these refugees. While these funds are apparently not needed by the States in the current fiscal year. we specifically provided that the unused balance would continue to be available in subsequent fiscal years to address the expected higher level of need in the final years of the program. A number of State governments. including my own. inform meand justifiably sothat tapping the legalization reimbursement funds would not be wise policy. The States have programs in place. they can spend the money allocated to them. and to transfer it elsewhere would be to renege on a deal that was struck with them on the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986. I am fully aware that for foreign policy reasons we will have persons leaving their homelands who we may wish to accept. whether or not they are truly refugees. I have no objection to making a special provision for that type of immigrant. I suggested to the Secretary of State a year ago that we needed a new category of foreign policy immigrant for persons such as some of those now receiving exit visas from the Soviet Union. Some individuals may have relied on statements of our Government which led them to believe that the United States would always accept them if they were to emigrate. Others we may wish to accept simply to make a foreign policy statement. I look forward to the legislative proposal which the administration is preparing in order to deal with this type of immigrant. It will be very difficult to establish the criteria for use of this type of visa. What may work for the Soviet Union may not be suitable for Asia and Latin America. Some interest groups will always oppose it if Federal funding for the settlement of these immigrants is not included. Such a category will likely not be large enough to include all immigrants of this type who may wish to enterjust as we cannot accept all of the true refugees who may wish to enter. or all of the normal flow of immigrants who wish to enter. We are facing some tough situations just like the current one In the Soviet Union where only a few hundred persons were receiving exit visas last January. but by December. 4.000 persons were given exit visas. Some estimate that as many as 100.000 Soviets may be allowed to leave in the next year. We cannot take them all. and It is so very important to acknowledge that unlike so many others in the world. most emigres leave the Soviet Union with a visa to enter Israel. They are not faced with the alternative of admission to the United States. or return to the Soviet Union. Most Soviet emigres have two "safety nets:" First. visas to Israel. and second. offers of parole into the United States. if their refugee application is refused. No other refugee group has these safety nets. We must explore this further along with so many other aspects of the issue. I do look forward to receiving the new legislation from the administration. and I especially look forward to the opportunity it will give us to have a new. full and complete debate on our refugee policy.
Keywords matched
immigrant Immigration Refugee visa emigrate immigrants migrants visas refugees refugee

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Vietnamese Soviets Nicaraguans
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Legal / procedural Humanitarian

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALAN SIMPSON
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
WY
Gender
M
Date
1989-03-02
Speech ID
1010006170
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →