Session #101 · 1989–91

Speech #1010003992

Iraq. has funded their activities in Pakistan. enabling them to buy houses in some of Karachis best neighborhoods. Their presence last year set off a national debate in Pakistan about the nations generosity to the displaced. It came after an Iranian hit squad launched a fullscale bomb. rocket and machinegun attack on a Mujahideen Khalq house early one morning. rudely awakening the refugees neighbors. including some of the most influential families in Pakistan. The battle transformed one of Karachis wealthiest suburbs into an Iranian battleground for a few brief. bloody minutes. No matter how wellrun a UNHCR operation can be In any given country. people who need services fall through the cracks. Perhaps 200.000 Afghan refugees live in Pakistan without being registered with UNHCR. Many. perhaps the majority of them. do so out of choice. usually because they want to live in a city and find work on their own. rather than being stuck in a rural camp. Tens of thousands of them. however. are in desperate need of UNHCR assistance but are blocked by Pakistani corruption. Nations of first asylum can write their own rules. Pakistan uses its own civil servants in all phases of the Afghan refugee effort. including registration for UNHCR benefits. Registration officials are thought to charge Afghans "registration fees" of up to $200 per person at some points on the border. If the refugees dont pay. they dont get ration cards or a place in a UNHCR camp. The knottiest problem here for UNHCR. however. is the thousands of Iranian boys and young men who have traveled danger. ous roads to escape the draft and the war against Iraq. Draft dodging is not a legitimate qualification for refugee status. no matter whose war Is being avoided. Most of these young men are from wealthy or middleclass Iranian families who supported Khomeinis predecessor. the late Shah Pahlavi. Many have family members in the U.S. and desperately want to get there. Their parents have the money to smuggle them out. but once they are inside Pakistan. UNHCR can do little for them. "The big problem is that UNHCR doesnt accept draft dodgers as refugees." said a UN official in Karachi. "Their cases as refugees are rejected. but Pakistan allows them to stay unofficially to work out their own lives." The truly rich get themselves to Europe or the U.S. rather easily. The majority become a sort of nonpeople. prey to all sorts of con artists and Karachi lowlife. Hamid Reza Hashemi arrived in Pakistan from Mashhad.
Keywords matched
refugee refugees

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Afghans
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural Other

Speaker & context

Speaker
Unknown
Party
—
Chamber
—
State
—
Gender
—
Date
1989-02-09
Speech ID
1010003992
Paragraph
#11
← Prev Next →