Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000272496

Mr. President. I rise to express some very serious reservations about H.R. 5115. a bill which increases the numerical limits on immigration. also changes the means by which we select immigrants to the United States. and permits foreign nurses working here on temporary visas to remain for 1 additional year in order to address a national nursing shortage. Mr. President. I have long argued on this floor in support of legal immigration reform since I introduced the first version of the Immigration Reform and Control Act more than 6 years ago. but I am troubled by some provisions of this bill. First. the bill provides that an additional 15.000 immigrant visas per year. for 2 years. will be distributed to immigrants from 36 countries which. 25 years ago. were the principal sources of immigration to the United States. I do not object to the diversity in immigration sought by this provision. but I do object to the admission of immigrants without any selection crtieria whatsoever. Such a process is not in the national interest. This body passed a comprehensive immigration reform bill in March that Senator TED KENNEDY and I floor managed. which created a carefully crafted point system by which we would select immigrants on the basis of age. education. occupations needed in the United States. and English language ability. A selection process based on those criteria is. in my mind. a much better immigration policy. and a policy that is truly in the national interest. Mr. President. the second provision of this bill would make available. through a lottery system. an additional 10.000 visas per year for 2 years to persons from countries which have not been using their share of immigrant visas. As we understand it. more than 160 countries will qualify for the lottery. Again. the immigrants will be selected at random with no selection criteria. As with the first provision I described. this amounts to an abdication of responsibility by the Congress to decide which immigrants would best serve our interests. I think what is particularly troubling about the second provision is the precedent it will set. For many years now. we have admitted immigrants to the United States based upon their family connections with residents of this country. or on the basis of a job offer from a U.S. employer for a position that could not be filled by a U.S. worker. I believe it is unwise to now revert to some random. or "lottery." selection of immigrants. That is surely not in the national interest. The third provision of this bill will extend the temporary worker status of certain foreign nurses working in the United States through December 31. 1989. This provision is occasioned by the acute shortage of nurses in our hospitals and clinics. and is obviously a stopgap measure. It is exactly this type of shortage which Senator KENNEDY and I addressed with the immigration reform bill the Senate passed in March. That bill gave special preference to persons in occupations which are needed in the United States and it gave additional points to those who have had experience or special training in those occupations. A country that admits more than a half million legal immigrants a year should certainly be able to find a way to include among those admitted immigrants who have occupations which are needed in this country. such as nurses. I am particularly concerned that if we are to continue passing stopag measures such as this bill. there will be increasing pressure on the Congress to extend such measuresas we are doing today for the nurses holding temporary worker visas. and for applicants under the "NP5" programrather than enact legislation which will provide a thoughtful and rational immigrant selection system. We have witnessed recent attempts to extend programs. such as the amnesty program. which were described as "one time only" proposals. I believe we will see efforts to extend the programs this bill proposes as well.
Keywords matched
immigrant Immigration immigration immigrants visas

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALAN SIMPSON
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
WY
Gender
M
Date
1988-10-20
Speech ID
1000272496
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →