Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000261388

Malaysia. Indonesia. the Philippines. Singapore. and Hong Kong for their past human assistance to refugees from Indochina. Given the serious political. economic. and religious persecution still occurring in Vietnam. Laos. and Cambodia. thousands of their citizens are forced to flee their homelands in search of freedom. The countries of Southeast Asia which have traditionally opened their doors to these refugees have been greatly affected by the 100 percent increase in this years outflow of Vietnamese boat refugees. Hong Kong. one of the smallest geographically. has been the most severly affected with a 500 percent increase in the number of Vietnamese boat refugees seeking shelter. from 3.000 in 1987 to 18.000 in 1988. Unfortunately. because of the sudden increase in boat people this year. hundreds of refugees in small boats have been denied the chance to land in the region. tragically many drowned as they were returned to the open seas. Others have been forced to return to Vietnam. While the overall number of Vietnameses refugees seeking asylum is small compared to the flood tides of 1979 and 1980. these 48.000 new arrivals have. nevertheless. caused serious political problems. particularly in Hong Kong. Malaysia. and Thailand. These nations are still hardpressed to provide for the needs of their own citizens. Weary of receiving and assisting refugees. some local officials have sought to portray all the boat people as economic migrants ineligible for assistance or asylum. and as a threat to the well being of their own citizens. Thus Malaysia decided to close its main refugee camp and threatens to deny asylum next year to any newcomers. Yet. United Nations High Commission for Refugees officials maintain that the vast majority of the Vietnmese they have been permitted to interview have similar backgrounds. experiences. and fear of persecution if returned. as those who fled Vietnam in the past. The Governments of Vietnam. Laos. and Cambodia are unfortunately still characterized by political repression. serious human rights abuses. harsh and arbitrary legal systems. oppressive economic and social policies and severely restricted legal emigration. Such policies practically guarantee that some of their citizens will seek any means to leave their countries for a chance to live in freedom or to join their loved ones abroad. Thailand is the principal country of first asylum in the region. It shelters some 100.000 Laotian. Cambodian. and Vietnamese "foot" refugees as well as 15.000 boat people and another 300.000 displaced Cambodians. These displaced Cambodians fear a return to their homeland until Vietnam withdraws its forces and a negotiated settlement of the Cambodian conflict can be achieved that will prevent the return of the murderous Khmer Rouge to power in Phnom Penh. The presence of over 400.000 refugees and displaced persons. 13 years after the end of the war in Vietnam. puts a strain even in this nations great Buddhist humanitarian traditions. Thailands willingness to humanely shelter additional refugees has also been affected by its heavy burdens and as a frontline state. Hundreds of its soldiers and even its civilian border residents have been shelled. killed by Vietnamese landings. and threatened by attacks from hostile Laotian. Vietnamese. or PRK forces. Hmong and other highland Laotian refugees closely allied with the United States during the war have suffered. as Thailand has sought to limit its hospitality to refugees. Some of these wouldbe refugees were the families of the men who rescued our downed pilots from Laos. These hill tribes were denied admission to Thailand. even though that nation operates an effective UNHCR assisted refugee screening process. But screening programs can only be supported if they are done in conjunction with the UNHCR and follow international law and conventions. These programs should be operated in a fair and inclusive manner. so that all those seeking to be screened can obtain access to this process. and not merely a random group. or those who offer bribes. Repatriation of refugees can be supported only where we have the assurances people will not be subjected to harsh punishment and further persecution. Todays resolution urges Thailand. a close ally and friend of the United States. and Malaysia. Indonesia. Singapore. the Philippines. and Hong Kong to fully restore and maintain humane first asylum policies that offer assistance to all those fleeing persecution. The resolution calls upon our Nation. other resettlement countries. and the UNHCR to work together to provide assistance and resettlement opportunities to refugees unable to return to their homelands. so that countries of first asylum are not overburdened. The Congress also calls on the administration to get involved with the UNHCR. Hong Kong and the ASEAN countries to carefully prepare for a new international conference on refugees. This conference will seek to develop measures to ensure the humane treatment of refugees seeking asylum and to discourage the flight of those who are not refugees. The conference must also work to ensure the eventual resettlement by the international community of those refugees from Indochina who are unable to return to their homelands. Nine years ago another President. Jimmy Carter. helped to ensure a successful Geneva Refugee Conference because he worked with other responsible members of the international community to see that approaches and remedies were agreed to before the conference met. If this ASEAN initiated refugee conference is not also carefully planned and coordinated. it could join the ranks of tragic failures. such as the international conferences in Evian and Bermuda. which miserably failed to come to the assistance of those desperately trying to flee the Nazi Holocaust. The Congress commends the President for humanely increasing refugee admission targets for 1988 and 1989 to accommodate the increasing number of refugees able to leave the Soviet Union. Eastern Europe. the Near East and Indochina. Refugees admitted to the United States have traditionally proven themselves to be genuine assets to our society. with a deep respect and love for our democratic traditions. our heritage of freedom and responsibility. Mr. Speaker.
Identified stereotypes
Portraying all boat people as economic migrants ineligible for assistance or asylum.
Keywords matched
Refugees emigration Refugee asylum policies migrants seeking asylum refugees refugee

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Economic threat Security threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
STEPHEN SOLARZ
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
1988-10-06
Speech ID
1000261388
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →