Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000253692

Mr. President. we have before us the opportunity to eliminate an unnecessary. and most damaging. legacy of the McCarthy era: The denial of visas to aliens on the basis of their political beliefs. For 35 years after enactment of the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952widely referred to as the McCarranWalter Actideology was used to deny aliens entry into the United States. Colombian novelist Gabriel Garcia Marquez was excluded. as were Graham Greene. Pierre Trudeau. Primo Levi. and dozens of other prominent foreign citizens. On October 8. 1987. the Senate passed the Foreign Relations Authorization Act of 1988 and 1989. which included a permanent bar to such ideologically based visa denials. The legislation as enacted was straightforward: No alien can be excluded from the United States "because of any past. current or expected beliefs. statements. or associations which. if enaged in by a U.S. citizen. would be protected under the Constitution of the United States." However. a HouseSenate conference decided that this bar should remain in effect for only 1 year. pending the enactment of comprehensive legislation to amend other elements of McCarranWalter. Such broader legislation has not come before the Senate. Unless we act today to extend the bar against ideologically motivated visa de. nials. such denials could begin again on March 1. 1988. The exclusion of aliens on the basis of their political beliefs was made possible in part by section 212(A)28 of the Immigration and Nationality Act. That section allows the exclusion of aliens who are members of anarchist. Communist. or other proscribed organizations. or who advocate such proscribed beliefs. No evidence was required that an alien would engage in activities endangering U.S. security. or that admitting the alien would undermine U.S. foreign policy. And by excluding aliens whose only threats to us were their ideas. we exposed our Nation to needless ridicule and undermined the respect for free speech we hope to promote around the world. The legislation enacted last year to bar such visa denials preserved the Presidents authority to exclude aliens for reasons of national security. If an alien is a terrorist or a member of a terrorist organization. that alien canand shouldbe excluded. And if the administration determined that an individuals admission were to prejudice the foreign policy of the United States. this law permits his exclusion. In the past year. this law has had precisely the effect we intended. In some instances. the executive branch has reversed its position on visa cases in recognition of this legislation. In cases where the administration has continued to deny visas on ideological grounds. courts have used this legislation as the basis for overturning such denials. The administration has persisted in denying visas to Hortensia de Allende. widow of the former Chilean President. in part because she "spoke on womens issues and the need for nuclear disarmament" at an international conferenceaccording to a decision issued on April 13. by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. That same court decision took note of the legislation enacted last year. and after concluding that Allende was being excluded because of her beliefs. said that "we need go no further." The court orderd Allende admitted. But the legislative basis for such court decisions will soon expire. In proposing this amendment. we have amended the original Foreign Relations Committee language to respond to the concerns of my good friend the junion Senator from Wyoming . the ranking minority member of the Immigration and Refugee Affairs Subcommitte of the Judiciary Committee. In so doing. we have limited the laws scope to those seeking nonimmigrant visas. the vast bulk of those affected by the McCarranWalter Act. The provision before the Senate today will also only extend the McCarranWalter revision for 2 years. so that revising the act now will not prejudice efforts to enact a broader revision of the underlying law. Let us act again as we did last year to bar the denial of visas on the basis of ideology. And in so doing. let us reaffirm our Nations commitment to free speech and the unfettered competition of ideas.
Keywords matched
Immigration Refugee visas visa

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Security threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
DANIEL MOYNIHAN
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
1988-09-30
Speech ID
1000253692
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →