Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000250406

DC. DEAR MR. PRESIDENT: Members of the Committee on the Judiciary have now consulted with your representatives on the proposed refugee admissions for fiscal year 1989. as required by Section 207 of The Refugee Act of 1980 (P.L. 96212). We hereby concur in your proposal. with the following recommendations and requirements. While we continue to share your commitment. and that of our Nation. to a generous program of refugee assistance around the worldparticularly in meeting emergency protection and resettlement needswe are nonetheless concerned over the level and allocation of refugee admissions proposed for the coming year. especially in Southeast Asia. We voiced these concerns last year. and they have only grown over the year since so little progress has been achieved in dealing with them. Last year the Committee specifically outlined these concerns in its letter to you on September 29. 1987. We noted that: "The proposed numbers for this year have been increased. even as concerns over the policy directions of our refugee program have deepenedparticularly in Southeast Asia. Regrettably. we believe that if some of the Committees policy recommendations of past yearsespecially the need to pursue options other than just third country resettlement for Indochinese refugeeshad seriously been approached. there might not be the need today for high levels of refugee admissions. For the sake of the refugees we seek to assist. we must give more than lip service to the often quoted admonition that third country resettlement is the least preferred durable solution. compared to repatriation and local settlement." In one fashion or another. under both Republican and Democratic majorities. this Committee has repeatedly raised this issue over the past seven years. But as our policy in Southeast Asia has stalled on the treadmill of third country resettlementwith few other alternatives being successfully pursuedimpatience with the program has inevitably grown. We have repeatedly been assured during recent consultations that the Administration was developing more comprehensive "initiatives" to deal with the continuing flow of Southeast Asian refugeesespecially voluntary repatriation. the screeningout of nonrefugees. and local settlement. But when the end of the day comes. we see little or no evidence of a sustained effort to achieve these goals. much less evidence of actual progress. We can only state again. that there is a need for new policy initiatives on many different fronts in Southeast Asia. Otherwise we are likely to see an inhumane end to what has been an extraordinarily humane program. Evidence of this became apparent this year with renewed boat "pushoffs" and drownings and new policies of notsohumane deterrence. And to pursue resettlement alone will doom future refugees to even more severe actions. Therefore. we take this opportunity to make the following recommendations and observations: 1. The Committee wants careful monitoring of the allocation of first asylum resettlement numbers in Southeast Asia. so that their use will be for priority cases only and so that any unused numbers can be allocated to other regions shortchanged by this years proposed ceilings. 2.
Keywords matched
Refugee refugeesespecially refugees refugee refugeeshad

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
Unknown
Party
—
Chamber
—
State
—
Gender
—
Date
1988-09-27
Speech ID
1000250406
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →