They are not here with the consent of the governed and I think this goes to the very. very heart of representative democracy. We are not trying to take away any of the fifth or sixth amendment protections and privileges that they have been afforded them and allotted and protected. not only by this Chamber. but by the Supreme Court of the United States. we are not trying to take away any economic benefits this Chamber has allocated to them. any educational benefits. All we are saying to the committee and to the leadership in this House is give us a vote. let the 435 men and women who comprise this Chamber of the House of Representatives. based on a history of being able to determine what rights illegal aliens have in our political system. give us the opportunity to vote up or down on whether or not when they take the census in 1990 they should be included. I would like to read a couple of things to my colleagues and then I would certainly conclude. The Supreme Court in 1982 recognized the distinction between the economic rights that these men and women here because of desperate situations have and their political rights. And it said in the Cabell. "Selfgovernment. whether direct or through representatives. begins by defining the scope of the community of the governed and thus of the Governors as well. Aliens are by definition those outside of this community." We are not trying to deprive them of benefits. we are not trying to do anything that would injure them socially or economically. All we are saying. and not only for ourselves but also for State legislators around the country. "If you are here as an undocumented alien. unable to vote. unable to work legally. you are here and you are citizens of another country. you should not be included for apportionment purposes in the 1990 census." I know my friend and colleague from New York wants to say something and I would be happy to yield to him at this time.
Keywords matched
undocumented illegal aliens