Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000210302

But. if that is so. then we ought to use that urgent need on their part to broaden the issue of human rights for the benefit of all of the peoples of the Soviet Union. those who wish to leave. and those who do not. consistent with our own tradition and our values. But I hear the Senator from Texas arguing on the other side: this is all irrelevant because MFN status will not be granted anyhow. Well. goodness gracious. if the Senator from Oregon is correct. and the Russians hear what the Senator from Texas is saying. we are not going to get any emigration anyhow. The Senator from Texas may be reading this body correctly when he says that we will not now or under any conditions grant MFN status to the Russians. But that is directly contrary to the arguments of those who say the McClure amendment undercuts JacksonVanik. Because if indeed that is the case that under no circumstances will MFN status be granted by this Congress. then there is no leverage for JacksonVanik. I remind my colleagues that when the Romanian MFN status was before this body for debate and a vote. it was turned down. But it was not turned down on emigration aloneas a matter of fact. their emigration policy was not that badit was turned down for human rights reasons. That is precisely the same idea as this amendment with respect to the Soviet Union. As the Senator from Arizona has very cogently noted. this is a softened version of the original amendment. a minimal statement. in my view. about what we should say to the Soviet Union about what we expect.
Keywords matched
emigration

Classification

Target group
None Specific
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
70%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JAMES MCCLURE
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
ID
Gender
M
Date
1988-06-28
Speech ID
1000210302
Paragraph
#3
← Prev Next →