Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000210275

I believe this provision would reinforce the concept of linkage between Soviet human rights policies and United StatesSoviet trade. It is this concept which lies at the heart of JacksonVanik. and It is this concept that some in the administration would like to abandon. Likewise. in our concern to increase emigration. we must not lose sight of the vast majority of Soviet citizens. Jews and others. who might not emigrate but who deserve the religious. political. and civil freedoms they have been promised under the Helsinki Act. JacksonVanik was enacted before Helsinki. So it does not address the broad range of human rights commitments the Soviets made there. It is important to remember why so many Soviet citizens want to emigrate in the first place. Additionally. under this amendment. the Soviets would not be able to satisfy JacksonVanik criteria by a temporary. and easily revoked. increase in emigration. Soviet emigration policies can be changed overnight. But once MFN status is granted and contracts are signed. it will be next to impossible to turn off the flow of trade. As the experience of the gas pipeline deal shows us. trade levers us a lot more than it levers them. "Havent the Soviets already made great strides in human rights?" Gorbachev has taken some impressive. but easily revocable. steps. For example. he has released over 380 political prisoners. allowed Sakharov to return to Moscow. released political prisoners held in psychiatric hospitals. allowed new latitude for the exercise of religious rights. and increased emigration. However. there is still no semblance of the rule of law as we in the West understand it or guaranteed political or religious rights. Despite rumors that they would be repealed or weakened. the most offensive laws remain on the books. for example the slander and "antiSoviet agitation and propaganda" articles of the Criminal Code. and the laws limiting and intimidating the practice of religion.
Keywords matched
emigrate emigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JAMES MCCLURE
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
ID
Gender
M
Date
1988-06-28
Speech ID
1000210275
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →