Using their logic. Congress should spend $1 billion to extend amnesty until the year 2000 and beyond on the theory that there will always be a relative handful of people who may some day wish to obtain amnesty but just havent gotten around to it yet. As Congress recognized when it passed the Immigration Reform Act in 1986. there comes a point where the Government and the taxpayers have done their share and the responsibility shifts to the eligible aliens. We must make them aware of the amnesty program. and we have. But in the end. the decision whether to apply is strictly their own. Finally. H.R. 4222 is a breach of faith that threatens future immigration reform initiatives. The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 was years in the making. as most Members in this and the other body will attest. Previously. major immigration bills were introduced in each successive Congress. only to go down in flames or simply to languish. unheard and unread. in committee. When the Immigration Act finally materialized in the fall of 1986. it was not without tradeoffs or political bloodletting. More importantly. the bills passage into law raised public expectations that Congress was finally going to bite the bullet and get on with the business of serious immigration reform. For that reason. many critics of the 1986 actand I count myself among themvowed to support the new law even though it failed to do many things we wanted with respect to employer sanctions. paperwork requirements. and so forth. Thus. it is not to be taken lightly that Congress agreed 2 years ago that the Amnesty Program should last until May 4. 1988. and that. thereafter. it should expire. I particularly object that H.R. 4222 is now being labeled a compromise because it extends the May 4 deadline for 6 months instead of a full year. as the gentleman from New York originally intended. In fact. the only thing H.R. 4222 compromises is the delicate consensus that made immigration reform possible 2 years ago. Mr. Chairman. H.R. 4222 betrays its intended purpose: to encourage eligible illegal aliens to step forward. Whatever its good intentions. this is seatofthepants policymaking. and it shows. It should be opposed on its meritsor rather. its lack of them.
Keywords matched
Immigration immigration illegal aliens