Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000175535

Mr. Chairman. I oppose this bill and a year and a half ago I opposed the 1986 Immigration Reform Act largely because I opposed the blanket amnesty provision which allowed illegal aliens to achieve legal resident status. No matter how much compassion I had for individual cases. I felt it was wrong to reward those who knowingly circumvented American immigration laws and unfair to those who stood in line for years and years to come into this country legally. For example. I have worked on cases in my district office where prospective immigrants with close relatives already living in the United States have waited 10 years to emigrate from Hong Kong. The situation is even worse for a Romanian man who has waited under harsh political circumstances for 6 years so that he may join his sister in New Jersey. In my opinion. the immigration problem we should be addressing are the laws which make it so difficult for Europeans to come to this country. That is why I find it incomprehensible that this body would now add insult to injury to those people who have waited faithfully and once again change the rules to favor those who continue to violate our laws. Now. lets be very clear on the facts: The legislation before us today would extend the legalization period till next November at a cost of $3 to $7 million per month. despite the fact that the U.S. Government has already spent millions of dollars to advertise the program and process the applications. and despite the fact that over 1.4 million illegal aliens have filed for residency. The Immigration and Naturalization Service has fulfilled its duty and obligation under the terms of the 1986 Immigration Reform Act. To its credit. the INS has in some cases ignored the letter of the law and allowed certain illegal aliens to stay in this country when they did not qualify for amnesty because the INS did not want to split up families. I think the INS should be commended for their humanitarian concern. Additionally. the INS is now permitting amnesty applicants to file simplified legalization forms by the May 4 deadline and then provide all the supporting documentation within 2 months after the deadline. In other words. the INS has already bent over backward to help as many people as possible qualify for amnesty. As for the argument put forward by supporters of this bill that we need to extend the legalization period because otherwise the sanctions placed on employers for hiring illegal aliens will be impossible to implement. This is a specious argument and one that is totally unsupportable. But aside from all the logic of the argument against this extension. there is a more fundamental issuethis bill sets a dangerous precedent. If we pass this bill what we would be saying to citizens and foreigners alike is that U.S. immigration laws are not to be taken seriously. but are there to be broken. I strongly oppose H.R. 4222. and I would urge my colleagues to vote against this legislation.
Keywords matched
Immigration Naturalization emigrate immigration immigrants illegal aliens

Classification

Also mentioned
Europeans
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
MARGE ROUKEMA
Party
R
Chamber
H
State
NJ
Gender
F
Date
1988-04-26
Speech ID
1000175535
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →