Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000175531

I rise in opposition to H.R. 4222 because. if passed. the net effect would be to take a bad idea and make it worse. The bad idea. of course. is the whole notion that we want to reward those individuals who came into this country illegally while at the same time penalizing those individuals who chose to attempt to come into this country legally. The reason it would penalize those individuals who chose to obey the law is those individuals who came in illegally take valuable space that is highly sought after and is competitively distributed through our immigration quotas. It also. however. ignores a very delicate political balance that was struck in the 99th Congress to get this bill passed in the first instance. I do not think anyone in this Chamber would deny the fact that the amnesty provision was the most divisive issue contained in the Immigration Reform Act that was passed in this body in the 99th Congress. The specific part that was highly contested was exactly how long we would allow the window of opportunity to remain open. The House version was 18 months. and the Senate version was 12 months. For those individuals who would argue this is insignificant. I would remind them the conferees reduced the time to 12 months in order to make certain that that delicate balance between employer sanctions and amnesty. and all of -the other various provisions that made up one of the most complex immigration reform bills ever pased in this body could in fact be passed. Now what we are doing is coming in through the back door and extending the legalization period from 12 to 18 months when in fact that delicate provision of amnesty passed by only seven votes in the last Congress. The second part of this bill that I think makes it bad legislation is the lack of necessity. I listened to the Commissioner of Immigration testify before the Subcommittee on Immigration that 96 percent of those individual aliens that are in this country that woud qualify are aware that they have the opportunity and have had the opportunity since last year to step forward and take advantage of this one time offer. According to testimony before the committee. the entire legalization process takes 30 minutes. What we are really arguing here is that in order to accommodate the procrastinators we are going to pass a bill that will end up costing the American taxpayers millions of dollars.
Keywords matched
Immigration immigration

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
PATRICK SWINDALL
Party
R
Chamber
H
State
GA
Gender
M
Date
1988-04-26
Speech ID
1000175531
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →