I say this because I am in full support of the vast majority of this bill. As my colleague. Senator SIMON of Illinois. and I stated in our additional views in the committee report. the bill makes a number of important and positive reforms to our Nations legal immigration policy. First. it requires annual executive branch review of our immigration policies. second. it increases second preference visas. and third. it makes available for the first time a number of "independent" visas for individuals who would like to enter the United States but have no family ties to this country. While this bill contains many positive reforms. each of these reforms can be accomplished without the changes the legislation makes in the fifth immigration preference. The drastic reduction in the number of visas available under the fifth preference for brothers and sisters of United States citizens and the limitation on future eligibility only to siblings who have never married are unnecessary to the overall bill and an unwise step away from the traditional importance we Americans have placed upon family reunification as a cornerstone of our national immigration policy. The changes made to the fifth preference are also contrary to the long study and recommendations of the 1981 Select Commission on Immigration and Refugee Policy. on which it was my distinct privilege to serve. The changes are also diametrically opposed to the considerable expert testimony given before the Immigration Subcommittee and the observations contained in the Subcommittees own staff report. "Legal Immigration to the United States: A Demographic Analysis of the Fifth Preference Visa Admissions." [S. Rept. 10034. U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary. April 1987.1 These reports all recommended that the present policy of admitting all brothers and sisters of adult U.S. citizens within the numerical limitations be continued. As was made clear in the committee report. the changes this bill makes to the fifth immigration preference hit potential immigrants with a double whammy. First. the bill drastically reduces the number of available fifth preference visas by 20 percent to 52.000 in the first 3 fiscal years of its implementation and by 67 percent to 22.000 thereafter. This reduction only serves to make an intolerably long backlog for fifth preference visas even longer. Second. and compounding the numerical reduction. is the requirement that fifth preference visas be granted only to brothers and sisters of U.S. citizens who have never been married. The effect of this unfair restriction is that siblings will have to remain unmarried throughout the entire waiting period. Given that the current backlog is over 10 years for some countries. future applicants under the fifth preference will be forced into the unacceptable choice of staying unmarried for a decade or more. or foregoing their eventual reunification with a brother or sister in the United States. Mr. President. reducing the availubUliy u LLJI preferencet ailUy reunification visas is detrimental to the national interest. The importance of fifth preference to family reunification was made eloquently clear by the American Committee on Italian Migration in testimony in the 97th Congress: For ItalianAmericans and for many other ethnic groups. brothers and sisters. whether or not they are married. are an integral part of the family reunion concept. Elimination of this preference category would violate a sacrosanct human right of an American citizen to live with his family according to his own traditional lifestyle. In conclusion. Mr. President. while the bill makes positive reforms in some areas of immigration law. I am unable to support it because of the fifth preference provisions which I believe to be both unfair and a radical departure from our historical immigration policies on family reunification.
Keywords matched
Immigration family reunification Refugee immigration immigrants visas Visa