Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000160455

Mexico. and the Dominican Republic. I am also pleased that the double penalty for applicants over age 40 has been removed from this bill. I had been concerned that the legal immigration bill could relinquish to the executive branch too much authority to set and change visa allocations to the detriment of our national immigration policy. The original version of this bill would have allowed for vast changes in family preference visas. for example. and Congress would have been left with the ineffective prospect of undoing those changes by legislative veto. S. 2104 specifies that any change in visa numbers greater than 5 percent requires affirmative approval by both Houses of Congress. Congress owes it to the Nationour immigrant origins and our pluralistic futureto give careful scrutiny to changes in our immigration policy. Too often in our history public fervor has ignited immigration exclusion laws which more careful and dispassionate analysis and thought could have prevented. S. 2104 requires triannual review of our immigration policy by the executive branch. including the Departments of State. Labor. Justice. and Health and Human Services. and Congress. This reform makes sense. One aspect of S. 2104 which I cannot support is its limitations on the fifth immigration preference. The fifth preference enables the brothers and sisters of U.S. citizens to be reunited with their families. It is the most widely requested visa type and its continued availability is of particularly strong importance to Americans of Asian. Hispanic. and Italian ancestry. S. 2104 unwisely and unnecessarily reduces the number of visas available under fifth preference by 20 percent in the first 3 years of enactment and by 67 percent thereafter. S. 2104 places a new requirement for future applicants for the fifth preference. For the first time. brothers and sisters of U.S. citizens will have to remain "never married" at the time they apply and throughout the waiting period for a visa. Because S. 2104 cuts the number of available visas and makes the now decadelong wait that much longer. the changes to fifth preference before us today will force prospective immigrants with the awful choice of forgoing marriage for 20 to 25 years or losing their chance to be reunited with their U.S. citizen brother or sister. 19059 08928 Pt 8) The changes made to the fifth preference run contrary to the long study and recommendations of the 1981 Select Commission on Immigration and Refugee Policy. considerable expert testimony at the Immigration Subcommittees hearing. and the observations contained in the subcommittees own staff report. "Legal Immigration to the United States: A Demographic Analysis of 5th Preference Visa Admissions" (S. Prt. 10034. U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary. As Gary Rubin of the American Jewish Committee told the subcommittee: One of the glories of our immigration system is that it responds to family values. Elimination of preferences for married brothers and sisters would detract from this commitment. It would indeed be ironic if at a time when Congress is struggling to reintroduce family values into the Nations social welfare system. it at the same time cut these same values from the immigration laws. which are built on family concepts. We dont need to do this. (Testimony of Rubin. Subcommittee on Immigration and Refugee Affairs. October 23. 1987.) Others who have contacted me in support of efforts to retain the fifth preference include the Federation of Korean Associations. National Democratic Council of Asian and Pacific Americans. Chicago Japanese American Citizens League. Chicago Committee for Immigrant Protection. Organization of Chinese Americans. Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund. and the Asian American Legal Defense Fund. The cuts to the fifth preference are not required for the rest of the bill to go forward. The positive reforms of S. 2104 can be achieved without making these detrimental cuts in eligibility for and number of fifth preference visas. As this bill works its way through the legislative process. fifth preference should be restored.e
Keywords matched
immigrant Immigration Refugee visa immigration immigrants visas Immigrant Visa

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Asian Hispanic Italian
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Family values

Speaker & context

Speaker
PAUL SIMON
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
IL
Gender
M
Date
1988-03-17
Speech ID
1000160455
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →