Session #100 · 1987–89

Speech #1000155899

President. I wish to bring to the attention of my colleagues the unintended consequences of a law passed in the last days of the 99th Congress. When we passed the Immigration Marriage Fraud Act Amendments of 1986 we did so in order to deter what was a serious problemabuse of our immigration laws by citizens and aliens to illegally secure residency rights via a fraudulent marriage. During hearings on this legislation. witnesses testified about being duped by aliens claiming to be in love but who were only after immigration benefits. Others discussed their involvement in wellorganized marriage fraud schemes. Because we as a society value the institutions of marriage and family we make marriage one of the quickest and easiest ways to enter this country and receive a permanent resident card. However. in trying to ferret out those who abuse our marriagerelated immigration laws. recent news indicates we may have gone too far and are now infringing on the rights of those U.S. citizens and alien spouses who marry out of true love and respect for each other. Section 5 of the new law gives no opportunity for those who enter into bona fide marriages to demonstrate the validity of that marriage if the alien spouse was subject to deportation and married after November 10. 1986. It appears now that the operation of section 5. which requires that an alien who married subject to deportation must leave the country for 2 years. goes too far and infringes on the privacy and futures of married couples we had no intention of affecting. The cases I have heard about in Illinois. Connecticut. Oklahoma. and here in the District of Columbia strongly suggest that we take another look at this law. I believe that we can seriously address the problems of marriages entered into to get around our immigration laws without requiring all spouses who were subject to deportation at the time of the marriage to leave the United States for 2 years. I believe it is sufficient for newly married aliens to be granted conditional residency for 2 years and then to return later for review by immigration officials for their permanent resident status. Repealing section 5 does not take away from the central thrust of the lawto remove the incentive for fraud by delaying the residency benefit from marriage for 2 years. The INS can still
Keywords matched
Immigration immigration deportation

Classification

Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Criminal

Speaker & context

Speaker
PAUL SIMON
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
IL
Gender
M
Date
1988-03-03
Speech ID
1000155899
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →