He is an extraordinary person in following almost every single issue that comes before the Senate. How he does that I have only the deepest admiration for. I happen to chair the areas of veterans affairs and immigration and nuclear regulation. but he chairs Energy and Natural Resources and seems to follow everything in this Chamber. which is an extraordinary thing and I have the deepest admiration for it. The Senator from California. although new to this body. has riveted upon this issue of immigration reform in an extraordinary way and done an extraordinary job. as witnessed by his success and the extraordinary success of the socalled DeConciniWilson amendment of yesterday. a significant breaking of the logjam which was paralyzing this legislation. Now. with all that. I speak in opposition to the amendment for this reason: The purpose of the legislation is to improve control over illegal immigration. That is it. Increased enforcement is a very key part of that. This amendment would very effectively defeat that purpose by greatly diminishing the ability of the Immigration and Naturalization Service to enforce immigration laws in the very occupations and industries which are presently dominated by the illegal labor force. That is. I guess. irony No. 1. since we are speaking of ironies. This amendment would effectively eliminate border patrol farm and ranch checks. The Immigration Service does not have the resources available to process warrants. to travel from the site to rural areas. to prepare and sign affidavits and to obtain approval and issuance of the warrant by a magistrate. Anyone who has ever been involved in the practice of law knows that. and especially in rural areas of the United States. that is an impossibility. Further. the field crews who are involved in this type of illegal employment move rapidly. No. that would be an understatement. they move frantically from place to place when this type of activity is going on. which makes the obtaining of a search warrant a futile effort. This amendment would reverse several existing Supreme Court holdings on the application of the fourth amendment to open fields. The purpose of the fourth amendment is to protect privacy. not to aid an employer or field boss hiring illegal undocumented persons who are evading our immigration laws. That is not the purpose of the fourth amendment. As I understand the theory behind this amendment. and I hope I perceive it correctly. it is this: It is not fair that the INS can see into an open field when they cannot see into a factory. I perceive that that is the essence of the argument. So here we are seeking to pass a new and substantive law which protects the knowing employment of the illegal undocumented aliens. and we are presented with an amendment which will greatly reduce our ability to enforce that law. It would be a contradiction in every term to support this amendment if one truly does believe in control. Mr.
Keywords matched
Immigration Naturalization immigration undocumented border patrol illegal immigration