And now. this bill would use the social security card as a form of identification for work eligibility. I am by no means alone in these concerns. Several members of the Select Commission on Immigration and Refugee Policy concluded that this identifier system could harm civil liberties. In fact. the Select Commissions recommendation to use an identification card squeaked by with a bare onevote margin. The American Civil Liberties Union and the U.S. Civil Rights Commission. as well. recognize the great danger that this act could infringe on our precious rights to privacy and on other rights. Identification card verification is a misguided overreaction to violations of our immigration laws. The employer sanctions provisions in this bill also concern me deeply. I believe employer sanctions will be discriminatory. costly. and ineffective. I think they will lead to discrimination against those who appear to be foreign in our country. According to the General Accounting Office. employer sanctions have never deterred effectively either the hiring of undocumented workers or the flow of illegal immigrants in any of the 20 countries in which they have been tried. It is neither fair nor practical to make employers immigration policemen. Employers paperwork requirements alone are certain to fuel discrimination. Hispanics and Asians will be turned away because employers cannot be sure documentation is valid. and will fear sanctions. Since the employer sanctions provision requires that records be kept only after an employee is hired. no proof of this discrimination would survive. And the limited enforcement powers. jurisdiction. and a great case backlog of EEOC means that this discrimination will not be redressed. On the other hand. the light penalties and minimal risk of enforcement of the sanctions provide little reason to hope that employers who traditionally have exploited undocumented workers will stop doing so. A less expensive and more effective alternative to the employer sanctions law would be to enforce labor laws already on the books. There would be little profitability in exploiting undocumented workersand little incentive to hire themif minimum wage. OSHA and fair labor standards laws were strictly enforced. I have grave doubts whether this bill will even minimally affect our immigration problems. Its restrictions on lawful immigration will exacerbate the already existing visa backlogs. since fewer slots will be available. It can only promote more illegal immigration because of the substantially longer waiting period that visa applicants will face. Its provisions for importing temporary foreign farmworkers may increase the use of. and reliance on. such workers. at the expense of unemployed American farmworkers. In fact. the present unemployment rate for domestic farmworkers is among the highest in our land. It is ironic that. while this legislation purports to curb immigration to the United States in order to protect American workers. it opens the door for hundreds of thousands of temporary agricultural workers. These workersdependent on the good will of their employersare more docile and easy to exploit than American farmworkers. The major cause of illegal immigration is the economic disparity between our country and the countries from which the immigrants come. For our immigration policy to work. it must include international solutions. We must devote substantial time. effort. and resources to help underdeveloped nations improve their own economies. feed their own people. and realize opportunities to achieve a decent standard of living. Any immigration policy that fails to take into account Americas interdependent relationship with other nations. expecially with Mexico and Latin America. is neither realistic nor fair. I believe that the way to deal with the employment giving to those who are here without documents instead of to American citizens and a less expensive and more effective alternative to the employer sanctions law proposed in this bill would be to enforce labor laws already on the books. There would be little profitability in exploiting undocumented workers and little incentive to hire them if minimum wage. OSHA. and fair labor standards were strictly enforced. Mr. President. I have grave doubts as to whether this bill will even minimally affect our immigration problems.
Identified stereotypes
Generalization that Hispanics and Asians will be discriminated against due to employer sanctions.