Mr. President. the amendment is identical to the language proposed by the House committee. S. 529 would prevent a court already reviewing a deportation order from examining the legality of the procedure denying the applicant legalization. My amendment merely permits that court to examine the administrative record from the deportees legalization proceedings to see whether there has been a gross abuse of discretion or whether the findings of fact are directly contrary to clear and convincing facts contained in the RECORD as a whole. This very limited form of judicial review would not expand the burden of the courts. It would be available only when an improper denial of legalization is raised as a defense in a deportation proceeding already subject to judicial review. There is a strong reason to believe that. by providing an exclusive reasonable but limited means of court review for administrative proceedings on legalization. this amendment may actually narrow in a constructive way the judicial remedies available to aliens subject to deportation. The U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly recognized that there are millions of aliens within the United States. each of them. including those here unlawfully. involuntarily or transitory. entitled to the protection of the 5th and 14th amendments to the Constitution and especially to the due process clause of the fifth amendment. While a statutory scheme which purports to deny certain classes of aliens the privilege of judicial review may not in and of itself be unconstitutional. there is no way that the Federal courts can be prevented from examining particular abuses of that statutory scheme which amount to constitutional denials of due process of law any more than other courtstripping attempts have been effective. Thus my amendment will specify ground rules on a limited judicial review that otherwise might ultimately be imposed by the courts and it will prevent our immigration proceedings from becoming starchambers. It is vitally important that even those we eventually exclude leave knowing that the United States is. as it proudly proclaims. a government of laws. The subcommittee technical amendment did not strengthen the bill.
Keywords matched
immigration deportation deportees