President. I ask unanimous consent that I be listed as a cosponsor of the amendment just sent to the desk by Senator KENNEDY. I would like to make a brief statement in support of the amendment by the Senator from Massachusetts that would reestablish judicial review for asylum cases. The judicial review provisions in S. 529 make a major modification of present law which is the Refugee Act of 1980. I think this is unwise for several reasons. First. The question of asylum cases should be addressed as part of the reauthorization of the Refugee Act. not as part of immigration reform. This was an argument made by the principal sponsor of immigration reform when the Senate considered immigration legislation last year and the Senator from Wyoming opposed amendments to the immigration bill that would have amended refugee policy. I think his position is a sound one and immigration policy is complicated enough without getting into refugee and asylum issues. Second. It probably is too early to know what modifications are required in the Refugee Act because INS enforcement of the act has not had enough experience to give us clear guidance on what changes might be warranted. This was pointed out in a report of the INS on asylum adjudication entitled "Asylum Adjudications: An Evolving Concept and Responsibility for the Immigration and Naturalization." This report concluded: Further. the Government publicized its inability to process this large volume thereby exacerbating the problem. The media also mistakenly publicized the view that all aliens were utilizing the multiple layer of appeals possible under the current law when in fact only about 2 percent of the cases. mostly class action suits. went beyond the administrative appeal machinery. Third. Although we have been hearing of the backlog of asylees for more than a year now. the INS report cited above implies that the backlog has more to do with staffing problems than judicial delays. The report on Asylum Adjudications says. in its conclusion: Is the current law with regard to asylum adjudications workable? We do not know the answer because the INS was never able to implement fully the asylum provisions of the 1980 Refugee Act.
Keywords matched
Immigration Refugee asylum cases Naturalization immigration refugee