Second. To upgrade the newly established U.S. Immigration Board by making them subject to Presidential appointments. with the advice and consent of the Senate. and totally independent of the Department of Justice. The bill. as it stands. makes the Board subject to the appointment and control of the Attorney General. Mr. President. in offering this amendment my goal is to make the asylum adjudication process both appear to be. as well as to be in substance. a genuinely independent and fair process. I support the thrust of the reforms contained in this bill. many of which were first recommended by the Select Commission on Immigration and Refugee Policy. upon which both Senator SIMPSON and I served. It is my hope that with the reforms contained in the billespecially the creation of a new U.S. Immigration Boardwill go far toward resolving the current problems and backlogs being encountered in the asylum adjudication process. But I believe these reforms fall short in the two specific areas I mentioned: The independence of the Board. and the provision of judicial review. Mr. President. in arguing for the elimination of judicial review from the asylum process. proponents say this is necessary because judicial review will result in delays and in the creation of huge backlogs. Well. Mr. President. this simply is not true today. and there is no sound reason to believe it will be so in the years to come. Currently. of the more than 150.000 asylum claims pending. less than 2 percent of these are in the courts. The facts are that the backlog is a consequence of the failure to provide sufficient funds and personnel to administer the asylum process. What we have today are administrative delays. not judicial delays. This has been confirmed by the study completed last December by the Immigration and Naturalization Servicethe conclusions of which I will enter into the RECORD later. According to the INS report: One question frequently asked is. "Is the current law with regard to asylum adjudication workable?" INS says: We do not know the answer because INS was never able to implement fully the asylum provisions of the 1980 Refugee Act. � . . Additionally. at the very time when the new asylum provisos went into effect in 1980. the Government actively encouraged the filing of irrelevant and frivolous claims. Further. the Government publicized its inability to process this large volume thereby exacerbating the problem.
Keywords matched
Immigration Refugee Naturalization asylum process asylum claims