Unfortunately. this is not true for several reasons: Title VII does not cover discrimination by employers who hire less than 15 workers. and Title VII does not cover discrimination for those hired for less than 20 weeks. thereby eliminating most agricultural workers. The amendment we are proposing would fill this void to assure that any new causes of employment discrimination would not go unpunished. and that we could deter such discrimination against primarily. against. our citizens. American citizens. who happen to look like that class of undocumented workers. We drafted our amendment to eliminate any overlap with the provisions of title VII to assure that an employer would be charged before the EEOC and then charged against another tribunal for the same alleged act of employment discrimination. This amendment specifically exempts from the definition of an unfair immigrationrelated employment practice discrimination because of national origin. If the discrimination with respect to that person and that individual is covered under section 703 of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Our amendment. therefore. does not interfer with the current jurisdiction of the EEOC. nor does it establish a system under which an employer could be accused in two separate arenas for one alleged case of discrimination. This amendment establishes a special counsel within the Immigration Board to investigate cases of alleged immigrationrelated discrimination. We have. therefore. avoided establishing any new apparatus with the Federal Government. We have been asked why the Immigration Board should be burdened with this additional responsibility. I believe the answer is simple: if the Federal Government does not accept this burden. then it will fall on those who will be discrimination against because of this legislation and who. without this amendment. will have no recourse. Those. again. will be American citizens frequently. both native born and naturalized. and those resident aliens that have been legally admitted to the United States. but who happen. because of their national origin. to resemble those undocumented workers that this legislation is intented to exclude from employment. By passing this immigration bill with its employersanctions provision. we are creating a likelihood that a whole new class of discrimination will emerge. Even if only 1 percent of Hispanics experience immigrationrelated discrimination. that would be more than 146.000 cases. If only onehalf face discrimination. that number is still 70.000. 70.000 people who may not get a job they would otherwise have gotten but for this legislation are considering today and tomorrow. I might add that by directing the application of this amendment to those employers who are not covered by title VII. we will focus on the very areas of employment where Hispanics are frequently working: employers of less than 15 workers and jobs for less than 20 weeks. In the last week. we have listened to the advice and criticism of many of our colleagues and I believe that the amendment before the Senate now meets all the constructive criticisms brought to our attention. I hope the manager of the bill and the chairman of the subcommittee will be able to find some merit in this amendment so that we can find a way to protect American citizens and aliens who are legally admitted to the United States with the full protection of the law against discrimination which is likely to arise from a bill which requires employers. in effect. to discriminate against illegal aliens. I thank the Chair.
Keywords matched
Immigration naturalized immigration undocumented illegal aliens immigrationrelated