Session #98 · 1983–85

Speech #980041425

There was ample unrebutted evidence that (the Haitians) were denied equal protection of the law. as mandated both by the Constitution and our interpretation of the Congress enabling legislation." According to the New York Times of April 14. the court determined also that the detained Haitians had not been adequately informed of their rights to petition for political asylum and to seek legal counsel. We are obliged to consider what remedy should be provided for the uniquely difficult circumstance of the Haitian boat people. exacerbated by the blatantly discriminatory treatment they have suffered during their time in the United Statesfor what other reason exists for the shameful manner in which they have been abused than that the color of their skin is black? Provision relating to the situation of these refugees is included as section 301 of S. 529. But this provision falls well short of regularizing the status of the Haitian boat people. Recently. a number of distinguished and respected observers of the American judiciary have pointed to the unfairness of excluding from the legalization provisions of S. 529 this group of immigrants. On behalf of the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights. Benjamin L. Hooks wrote to me on April 28: Other Haitian refugees otherwise indistinguishable from this class. arriving prior to the illegal detention program. have already benefited from President Carters decision to grant then "entrant" status. Fundamental justice demands that the boat people who have fled to our shores seeking safety and who have suffered additionally under illegal detention. benefit from these same protections. It is simply unjust and cruel for the Immigration Service to continue to threaten this small group of Haitian boat people with forcible deportation * * * A similar appeal has been voiced by spokesmen for 35 community. labor. civil rights. and religious groups in southern Floridathe region of the country most directly affected by the Haitian arrivals: Should a partial legalization program not include the previously detained Haitian boat people. elementary justice demands that separate provision be made in the legislation granting legal status to Haitians arriving before January 1. 1982. thereby recognizing their unique plight and suffering. I support the goals of a legalization program in the Simpson immigration bill. The Judiciary Committees report of title III of S. 529 specifies in part that the legalization be a "onetime only" program that eliminates the subclass of undocumented persons who now constitute a clearly exploitable group within U.S. society and sap unnecessarily the resources of law enforcement agencies. To achieve this goal. a legalization program must be as comprehensive and current as possible. Mr. President. I urge that the SenateHouse conference committee carefully consider the merits of a truly comprehensive legalization program. Such provision would be the fairest and most practical solution to the unique plight of the Haitian refugee boat people. who continue to face forcible deportation to Haiti. I ask that there be printed in the RECoRn at this point the text of the letter to which I have referred from Mr. Benjamin L.
Keywords matched
Immigration immigration immigrants undocumented deportation refugees refugee

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Positive
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural Victim

Speaker & context

Speaker
DANIEL MOYNIHAN
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
1983-05-12
Speech ID
980041425
Paragraph
#2
← Prev Next →