Senator SIMPSON. as well as Senator DECONCINI and Senator MATHIASremain the most recent. and the most thoughtful argument against the very amendment being proposed by Senator HELMS to eliminate the legalization program proposed in the pending bill. Mr. President. for the record I would like to read the very carefully considered. in fact. the restrained recommendations. of the Select Commission on the importance of establishing a legalization program in any package of immigration reforms considered by Congress. First. the Select Commission voted unanimously to recommend that a program to legalize undocumented/illegal aliens now in the United States be adopted. The Commission held the view that the existence of a large undocumented population should not be tolerated. They found that: The costs of society of permitting a large group of persons to live in illegal. secondclass status are enormous. Society is harmed every time an undocumented alien is afraid to testify as a witness in a legal proceeding (which occurs even when he/she is the victim). to report an illness that may constitute a public health hazard or disclose a violation of U.S. labor laws. In seeking a solution to the problem of a large. resident undocumented alien population. the Select Commission has considered a range of programs. including massive deportation efforts. the use of existing enforcement procedures and legalization. Attempts at massive deportation would be destructive of U.S. liberties. very costly. subject to challenge in the courts and. in the end. ineffective. The only time in U.S. history when such a massive deportation effort occurred was in the mid1950s when the Immigration and Naturalization Service expelled or repatriated more than 1 million aliens. This was done at tremendous cost in terms of both money and personnel. and. more importantly. violated the civil liberties of many Mexican Americans who were forcibly repatriated to Mexicc. Such an effort would not be tolerated today. However carefully designed and implemented. any program to remove 3.5 million to 6 million people would almost certainly violate the rights of many legal residents without reaching more than a small proportion of those aliens lacking proper documentation. Mr. President. the Commission felt that simply continuing existing enforcement techniques would only insure the continuation of current problems. and we concluded that legalization is the only realistic response to the problem of resident undocumented aliens. Specifically. the Commission found that: 1. Qualified aliens would be able to contribute more to U.S. society once they came into the open. Most undocumented/illegal aliens are hardworking. productive individuals who already pay taxes and contribute their labor to this country. 2. No longer exploitable at the workplace because they are unwilling to avail themselves of the protection of U.S. law. legalized aliens would no longer contribute to the depression of U.S. labor standards and wages. 3. Legalization is an essential component of the Commissions total package of recommendations to stem the flow of undocumented/illegal migrants and will aid in the enforcement of U.S. immigration laws. It will enable INS to target its enforcement resources on new flow of undocumented/illegal aliens. 4. For the first time. the United States would have reliable information about the sources (specific towns. villages and provinces) of undocumented/illegal migration and the characteristics of undocumented/illegal aliens. This information will further facilitate enforcement efforts to curtail future flow. It will also enable the United States to focus bilateral or unilateral aid and investment programs in ways that might deter migration at its source. In addition. Mr. President. many of us on the Commission felt that a legalization would also acknowledge the fact that the United States has had some responsibility for the presence of undocumented aliens in our countrysince our laws have explicitly exempted employers from any penalty for hiring them. namely. the socalled Texas proviso. This officially sanctioned policy has been the pull that has brought them here. Because of this partial responsibility. the alternatives to legalizationsuch as continuing to ignore their plight or initiating mass deportation effortswould. in addition to being harmful to the United States. also constitute unfair penalties on aliens and their familiesespecially those who already have the necessary qualifications to reside here legally. although they do not know it. In conclusion. Mr.
Keywords matched
Immigration Naturalization immigration migrants undocumented deportation illegal aliens