Session #98 · 1983–85

Speech #980038696

Mr. President. today I am introducing the Federal Alien Incarceration Responsibility (FAIR) Act. This legislation will require the Federal Government to reimburse States for the cost of imprisoning illegal aliens. aliens admitted in excess of normal quotasparticularly those entering on the Cuban and Haitian boatliftsand aliens here on temporary visas. who have been convicted of a felony. Hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants now enter the United States annually. Some have estimated the yearly undetected inflow of illegal aliens at 500.000. The Immigration and Naturalization Service apprehends nearly 1 million illegal aliens every year. Yet. there are at least 3.5 million. and possibly as many as 12 million. illegal aliens in the United States today. Since World War II. 1 V2 million refugees have fled to this country. Hundreds of thousands of Indochinese. Cubans. and Haitians have also been permitted to enter the country in recent years in excess of normal quotas. 7 million nonimmigrant students. migrant workers. and other visitors enter this country on temporary visas every year. It is important to understand why. under this legislation. some categories of aliens will trigger Federal reimbursement. while others will not. Simply stated. there will be Federal reimbursement for State expenditures in connection with alien felons in those cases in which there is no adequate Federal safeguard protecting the States from large influxes of potential criminals. When illegal aliens. refugees. migrant workers and others admitted on temporary visas are permitted to enter the country. they are admitted according to no set numerical quota. Their admission is essentially a matter of Department of State discretion. The decisionmaking process is one in which foreign policy considerations dominate over the need to safeguard and protect American citizens. Federal reimbursement will not be required in cases of aliens admitted under numerical quotas because in such cases Immigration and Naturalization Service screening offers the States a substantial measure of protection. An adequate screening process and the very fact of family ties also can protect the States when relatives of American citizens are admitted. For this reason. this class of immigrants is also excluded from Federal reimbursement. Finally. this legislation excludes diplomats because diplomatic immunity prevents their incarceration in the United States. The problem of prison overcrowding has assumed the dimensions of a national crisis. The pressures created by additional thousands of illegal aliens. asylees. and nonimmigrants threaten to overwhelm our State prison systems at the very moment that they are struggling to cope with the largest prisoner population increase in history. A survey of State prison systems carried out by the New York Department of Corrections disclosed that approximately 1 percent of State prisoners are aliens. It is estimated that there are close to 24.000 aliens incarcerated for felony offenses in State prisons.
Identified stereotypes
Generalization that illegal aliens are potential criminals.
Keywords matched
Immigration illegal immigrants Naturalization immigrants visas refugees migrant illegal aliens

Classification

Also mentioned
refugees migrant workers
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Criminal Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALFONSE DAMATO
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
1983-05-10
Speech ID
980038696
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →