Session #98 · 1983–85

Speech #980032395

From a practical standpoint if this bill is passed by the Senate. if for some reason it passes the House and it is signed by the President and becomes law. then there will be a mass production of employment records to grant amnesty for people. and we will never find the end of the numbers of people who are coming in. But the problem still is at the borders. as long as the standard of living directly to the south of the United States is such a differential between the standard of living and the opportunities we find in the country to the south. in Mexico. as we have in this country. as long as we have that differential between those countries. as long as we have the threats of tyranny and the expansion of the MarxistLeninist revolution in Central America this problem is going to get worse whether we pass this bill or not and those same people who have produced the documents that the good Senator has on the floor today will just produce more of them but they will add one more thing to them. they are going to add employment records and they can then verify that such and such has worked for 5 years or so long. in the United States. and then after that time period they will be free and clear to stay here and it will go on and on and on and the problem will be compounded and will become more difficult. I will say again to my friend I think until we address what some of the problems are that brought about the symptoms of massive immigration into this country. and you have to say it is a compliment to the intelligence of those people who are emigrating. whether legal or illegal. that they have recognized this is a better place to be than anyplace else on the face of this Earth. and that is what the problem is and my good friend from Wyoming is doing the best job. and I would say even though I do not support this legislation he is doing the best job possible to try to address the problem but it is impossible for us to pass legislation here to try to put the entire burden of enforcement on the small businessmen and farmers in America and have a successful operation. Because what we are simply doing is we are trying to accomplish something that simply cannot be accomplished under the means that we are asking people to accomplish it. That is my whole opposition to the proposition we have here. Now if we could have a liberalized answerand the Senator asked me a question what would we do. I say we should allow a million undocumented workers a year to come in under the guest worker program to fulfill the reApril 28. 1.988 sponsibilities and the jobs that are asked for the perishable crops in California and in the other produce producing States in the West. in the Southeast. to fulfill those jobs that American citizens do not want. then after that we could start addressing this problem. But the way this legislation is writtenand I know the Senator is going to get up and talk about the H2 program. but I can say from practical experience the H2 program simply does not address the problem that the good Senator from Arizona. Senator DECONCINI. and Senator WILSON. from California. addressed. and that is how do the perishable commodities get harvested when you have to wait for the bureaucracy to grind it through the process?
Identified stereotypes
Generalizes that people immigrate to the US because it is a better place to live.
Keywords matched
undocumented immigration emigrating

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
STEVEN SYMMS
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
ID
Gender
M
Date
1983-04-28
Speech ID
980032395
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →