Session #98 · 1983–85

Speech #980032225

This amendment is being submitted on behalf of myself. Senator KENNEDY. and Senator CoCHRAN. It provides for a reporting procedure requiring that the President send to Congress a report on the levels of immigration and the impact that level of immigration is having. For many years. we have legislated about immigration without sufficient timely information. I can recall standing here only 3 years ago. debating whether or not to place a limit on legal immigration for that fiscal year. The debate over whether or not to place such a limit was quite straightforward. there was general agreement that a limit was necessary. But. despite the efforts of Senators DECONCINI. DANFORTH. SARRANES. and MATHIAS. and telephone calls to the State Department and INS. we could not find out exactly how many people had been admitted as immigrants in either that year or the year before. The result of this lack of information was that we legislated in ignorance. We fumbled about. trying to find a way to draft language to accomplish the task at hand in a relative. instead of an absolute. fashion. This kind of incident is all too common in immigration. We are forever trying to get information that should have been provided to us years before. That is not the fault of the Immigration Subcommittee. they do very well to get as much information as they can to us. But the information is not being compiled by the executive branch. The Immigration and Naturalization Service is supposed to produce an annual report each year. with current information. Unfortunately. the INS is usually years behind in publishing its reports. I am not placing all of the blame on the INS. that agency is seriously underfunded and overworked and part of the reason we are here today is because the INS has not had the resources to do its job for the last few years. But the fact remains that we have not received the kind of information we need to legislate on this issue. It is a testament to the ability of the members of the Immigration Subcommittee. and its chairman. Senator SIMPSON. that they have been able to move as far as they have without the kind of full and complete data that we take for granted in many other fields. I believe that it is time for us to require the most basic information be provided to the Congress on a timely basis. That requirement is contained in my amendment. My amendment requires the President to review periodically the level of immigration to the United States. and to report on those levels to Congress. In the House. which has adopted this mechanism in its immigration reform bills. this mechanism is called periodic review. In 1980. with the cooperation of Senator KENNEDY. we placed similar requirements in the Refugee Act of 1980. Under those requirements. Congress must be provided with certain basic information each year. That information has been most helpful. and I believe that everyone agrees that those reporting requirements have been extremely helpful. However. even they fall far short of the comprehensive information which is needed. My amendment will require the same type of reporting be done for all immigration. not just refugees. The President would be required to send to Congress a report on the levels and impact of immigration. In the report. the President must report how many immigrants were admitted. the basis on which those immigrants were admitted. and the impact of those admissions on the United States. The report must also estimate the number of illegal entries to the United States. and must project. to the best extent possible. what the President expects for immigration in the near future. The President is also given an opportunity to make recommendations on possible changes in the immigration laws. Upon the receipt of the report. the Judiciary Committees of the House and the Senate must hold hearings on the report. In the refugee admissions process. Mr. President. we have found similar hearings to be invaluable sources of information for Congress. My amendment does not require. as in the refugee admissions process. that the report be printed in the REcORD. It is my hope. however. that the Judiciary Committees will provide the public with the information in these reports by printing the reports in hearing records. along with any appropriate comments or supplementary information. I am not sure that there are any valid arguments against providing this kind of minimal information on a timely basis to Congress. I have not heard any. Perhaps the INS might object to making more reports to Congress. but this information is both necessary to our work. and available to be used. The reports from the field which could be used to calculate immigration totals are now sitting in boxes in the INS headquarters. No one is using these reports now until years after they are received. We. who need this information. should put those field reports to their intended use. This type of periodic review mechanism is and has been in the House version of the Simpson/Mazzoli bill. I understand that my amendment. or an amendment quite similar to it. will be offered in the House Judiciary Committee. A less specific amendment was already placed in the bill by the House Immigration Subcommittee. I want to stress. Mr. President. that my amendment makes no substantive change in the legal immigration portion of this bill or in current law. My amendment only requires the reporting of information and the holding of hearings. I suggest no changes in Senator SIMPSONS mechanism for establishing a ceiling on legal immigration. and no changes in the allocation of the visas available. My amendment is designed solely to provide information on a timely basis to Congress. I hope that the Senate will adopt my amendment. Mr. President. I believe that we in the Congress sorely miss having sufficient information on immigration. We would not tolerate this kind of lack of information in other areas. we should require better information on immigration. I urge the adoption of this amendment. Mr. President. my understanding is that the report shall include: Total admissions. the number of aliens admitted by category or type of admission or acquisition of permanent residence. the number of aliens whose petitions for admission or acquisition of permanent residence were filed by. or whose visas were approved on the basis of a relationship with. a person who was not a naturalborn citizen of the United States. and a reasonable estimate. substantiated by the best available evidence. of the number of aliens who entered the United States without visas or who became deportable under section 241. Any appropriate recommendations on changes in the numerical limitation on admissions in section 201 or other provisions of this title bearing on the admission of aliens to. or the acquisition of permanent residence in. the United States. An analysis of the impact of migration to the United States on the size and distribution of the U.S. population. The change in the size of the labor force caused by legal and illegal migration. together with estimates of the labor market characteristics and geographical distribution of these workers compared with the characteristics and distribution of the legally resident employed and unemployed labor force. The extent to which immigrants admitted under paragraph (1). (2). or (4) of section 203 and nonimmigrants admitted under subparagraph (H) or (L) of section 101(a)(15) have been used to meet labor needs of the United States. The cost and benefits to the Federal Government and State and local governments of the impact of the admission of immigrants. refugees. and asylees.
Keywords matched
Immigration Refugee deportable Naturalization immigration immigrants visas refugees refugee

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
refugees
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
WALTER HUDDLESTON
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
KY
Gender
M
Date
1983-04-28
Speech ID
980032225
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →