Mr. President. in 1981 the U.S. Attorney General and the Secretary of State entered into an agreement to circumvent the immigration laws of this country. At the urging of the Secretary of State. the Attorney General agreed to order the INS to "presume" that all individuals migrating from Laos. Cambodia. and Vietnam were refugees. This presumption would have automatically qualified those migrants for the extremely generous refugee resettlement program in the United States. Although no one knows exactly how much this resettlement program is costing U.S. taxpayers. a Presidential report released late last year revealed that total U.S. refugee assistance programs have cost about $9 billion over the last 4 years. At the time this agreement was being made there was evidence produced by Government officials in the field which showed that a substantial number of the "refugees" were really economic migrants. According to this evidence. many did not belong to that special group of people who we classify as refugees under our immigration laws because they were not fleeing persecution in their home countries. In essence. the refugee program was being used to operate a backdoor immigration program which was costing U.S. taxpayers billions of dollars. On July 22. 1981. I introduced Senate Resolution 191 which called for an immediate investigation of that situation. Following the introduction of this resolution. hearings on both the Senate and the House side were held which substantiated my charges that the immigration law was being circumvented. In fact. the Office of Legal Counsel of the U.S. Justice Department issued a legal memo which stated that the Attorney General had exceeded his authority and that the law did not permit such a blanket presumption. The memo went on to say that what the law requires is a casebycase review to determine if an applicant qualifies for that very special class of persons we refer to as "refugees." At one of the hearings. the Attorney General recanted on his agreement with the Secretary of State and assured the Congress that new guidelines would be issued. Although it took the Attorney General 9 months to issue these new guidelines. they were ultimately put into place. As a result of this skirmish. the INS officials who had balked at violating the immigration laws as a result of the presumption agreement were vindicated. It was clearly shown that INS officials were correct and that State Department officials were guilty of circumventing the law. . However. I have dealt with State Department officials for 7 years on this subject and I know that their determination is exceeded only by their nearsightedness on this issue. Accordingly. I knew that it would only be a matter of time before they would again attempt to escalate the refugee program in Indochina far beyond the intent of Congress. I have recently obtained copies of communications which reveal that the State Department is again attempting to circumvent the immigration law by classifying migrants as refugees even if they do not qualify under the law. State Department officials have again been putting extreme pressure on INS officials to resettle in the United States tens of thousands of migrants who are not refugees. Ambassador John Gunther Dean has been reported by reliable sources to have told INS that a denial rate of more than 25 percent would be "unacceptable" to him. In other words. the State Department wants to again institute a "presumption" that 75 percent of all migrants who are interviewed are automatically given the special classification of "refugee." This is an obvious departure from the letter and intent of the Refugee Act which Congress passed in 1980. Under this act. refugees are considered to be very special people who are deserving of a special kind of treatment. This is why we defined refugees as people who are fleeing persecution which is directed specifically at them in their own countries because of their political or religious activities. In other words. the true freedom fighters of the world were our intended beneficiaries. not economic migrants who simply want a better standard of living. Because true refugees are unique. we have extended to them the opportunity to resettle in the United States and a broad assortment of financial assistance programs. The Refugee Act of 1980 was not intended to be a backdoor immigration program. nor was it intended to be an international welfare program. However. this is exactly what the State Department has sought to create in Indochina. As a result. it should now be obvious to everyone that the State Department cannot carry out its function in the area of refugee resettlement in a responsible manner. The Department has consistently ignored the intent and letter of the law and permitted other objectives to interfere with its duties in the refugee program. If we are to preserve any respect at all for our already tattered and torn immigration system. I believe that the U.S. State Department must be substantially removed from any direct involvement in the system. Mr. President. because the statement I made in 1981 in regard to State Department manipulation of the Refugee Act is as pertinent today as it was then. I ask that it be printed in the RzcoRD. The statement follows:
Keywords matched
Refugee immigration migrants refugees refugee