Commerce and Navigation that each of them has concluded with the United States. The passage of this legislation would demonstrate that the United States is mindful of its treaty obligations. The legislation would make eligible for naturalization only a few of those resident aliens now debarred from citizenship. As permanent residents. these aliens already are living here and have most of the rights of citizens. except for a few which are of great symbolic importance to those who want to be citizens of the United States. The United States has nothing to lose and much to gain from permitting these treaty nationals to acquire the stature and responsibilities of citzenship if they are qualified in every meaningful respect. Moreover. naturalization would eliminate the need for the purposeless bureaucratic redtape that the U.S. Government must now administer in connection with these aliens. The legislative history of the McCarran Act states that "three classes of persons" are to be "permanently ineligible for citizenshipnamely. deserters. draft dodgers. and aliens who apply for and are relieved from training and service in the Armed Forces on the ground of alienage." Since that legislation was passed in 1952. amnesty has been granted to deserters and draft dodgers. despite the fact their actions were illegal.
Keywords matched
naturalization