Session #96 · 1979–81

Speech #960046948

I yield myself 8 minutes. Mr. Chairman. the Committee on the Judiciary restricted its consideration of this legislation to those sections of the administrations implementation proposal referred to it dealing with special immigrants. Following a hearing on these provisions. the Subcommittee on Immigration. CXXV754Part 10 Refugees and International law and the full Committee on the Judiciary unanimously recommended the deletion of the special immigrant provisions from the bill. I would like to explain briefly what the special immigration provisions would provide and why the Committee on the Judiciary unanimously calls for their deletion. First. the provision in this bill. H.R. 111. would in essence provide blanket authority for 286.000 current and former employees of the Canal Zone Government and the Panama Canal Company to immigrate to the United States. Covered would be 1year employees living in the Zone. 15year employees retired. 15year employees still working. and 1year employees not living in the Zone. The bill blankets in basically all employees who worked for the Canal Zone Government or the Panamal Canal Company for 1 year regardless of the nature of their services. They could have been discharged for improper conduct or dishonesty. as long as they have been employed for 1 year they would qualify under this legislation. Basically. the Committee on the Judiciary opposed this provision because in part present law provides for special immigrant status for faithful employees of 15 years or more in certain circumstances. The bill would also waive public charge requirements and health requirements of our immigration laws. Let me point out as well that this provision is not required to implement the treaty. Not only would present law basically deal with the problem of longterm faithful employees of the Panama Canal Zone Government and the Panama Canal Company. but no need was demonstrated by the State Department for this provision. The only justification for this provision was that it would sendand I quotea "psychological signal" to the present employees of the Canal Company. I do not believe that our immigration laws should be used as a psychological signal. and I certainly do not think they should be used as a psychological signal to the tune of virtually blanket admission of 286.000 immigrants. Let me say also that no estimate was provided as to how many of these former and present employees want to come to the United States as special immigrants or. as to those who want to come. how many of them would already be covered under present law. No showing was made that any discrimination would occur against any employees remaining in Panama after the treaty takes effect. State Department witnesses testifying on the provision noted that many of the current employees who do not qualify for "special immigrant status" under existing law will. in all likelihood. continue their employment with the Panama Canal Commission after the treaty goes into force. Their situation after the effective date of the treaty will remain unchanged. except that a few individuals currently living in the Zone will then be under Panamanian jurisdiction. Supporters of the legislation failed to demonstrate. given the significant job security prospects of these people. how the great majority of them would be adversely affected by the treaty. Indeed. no showing was made of any actual immediate need for enacting this virtually blanket immigration provision. I would say. as chairwoman of the Subcommittee on Immigration. Refugees. and International Law. that should a special circumstance or a special need be actually shown. I will do my best to accommodate that need. and I am sure the other members of the subcommittee feel the same way. In fact. that was discussed during our hearings. But in the absence of any clear. demonstrable need. it seems to me to be inappropriate to enact this provision. especially when there are hundreds of thousands of refugees and other people who want to come to the United States and who need to come to the United States. Here we have no showing that anybody wants to come to the United States or that they need to come to the United States. Mr.
Keywords matched
Refugees Immigration immigrant immigration immigrants immigrate refugees

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
refugees
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
ELIZABETH HOLTZMAN
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
NY
Gender
F
Date
—
Speech ID
960046948
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →